Letter LXXXV.
(a.d. 405.)
To My Lord Paulus, Most Beloved, My Brother and Colleague in the Priesthood, Whose
Highest Welfare is Sought by All My Prayers, Augustin Sends Greeting in the Lord.
1. You would not call me so inexorable if you did not think me also a dissembler. For
what else do you believe concerning my spirit, if I am to judge by what you have written,
than that I cherish towards you dislike and antipathy which merit blame and detestation;
as if in a matter about which, there could be but one opinion I was not careful lest, while
warning others, I myself should deserve reproof,2082 or were wishing to cast the mote out
of your eye while retaining and fostering the beam in my own?2083 It is by no means as you
suppose. Behold! I repeat this, and call God to witness, that if you were only to desire for
yourself what I desire on your behalf, you would now be living in Christ free from all dis-
quietude, and would make the whole Church rejoice in glory brought by you to His name.
Observe, I pray you, that I have addressed you not only as my brother, but also as my col-
league. For it cannot be that any bishop whatsoever of the Catholic Church should cease to
be my colleague, so long as he has not been condemned by any ecclesiastical tribunal. As to
my refusing to hold communion with you, the only reason for this is that I cannot flatter
you. For inasmuch as I have begotten you in Christ, I am under very special obligation to
render to you the salutary severity of love in faithful admonition and reproof. It is true that
I rejoice in the numbers who have been, by God’s blessing on your work, gathered into the
Catholic Church; but this does not make me less bound to weep that a greater number are
being by you scattered from the Church. For you have so wounded the Church of Hippo,2084
that unless the Lord make you disengage yourself from all secular cares and burdens, and
recall you to the manner of living and deportment which become the true bishop, the wound
may soon be beyond remedy.
2. Seeing, however, that you continue to involve yourself more and more deeply in these
affairs, and have, notwithstanding your vow of renunciation, entangled yourself again with
the things which you had solemnly laid aside,—a step which could not be justified even by
the laws of ordinary human affairs; seeing also that you are reported to be living in a style
of extravagance which cannot be maintained by the slender income of your church,—why
do you insist upon communion with me, while you refuse to hear my rebuke of your faults?
Is it that men whose complaints I cannot bear, may justly blame me for whatever you do?
You are, moreover, mistaken in suspecting that those who find fault with you are persons
who have always been against you even in your earlier life. It is not so: and you have no
2082 1 Cor. ix. 27.
2083 Matt. vii. 4.
2084 Cataqua (?).
To Paulus
812
To Paulus