in size as it is, when the proportions of the figures according to which it is framed do in no
way hinder its being enlarged to any extent desired? Or how might it not be said to me—nay,
might we not be compelled to admit that matter is infinitely divisible; so that, starting from
any given base (so to speak), a definite number of corpuscles must rise to a definite and as-
certainable quantity? Wherefore, seeing that we do not admit that any particle is so small
as to be insusceptible of further diminution, what compels us to admit that any assemblage
of parts is so great that it cannot possibly be increased? Is there perchance some important
truth in what I once suggested confidentially to Alypius, that since number, as cognisable
by the understanding, is susceptible of infinite augmentation, but not of infinite diminu-
tion,1445 because we cannot reduce it lower than to the units, number, as cognisable by the
senses (and this, of course, just means quantity of material parts or bodies), is on the contrary
susceptible of infinite diminution, but has a limit to its augmentation? This may perhaps
be the reason why philosophers justly pronounce riches to be found in the things about
which the understanding is exercised, and poverty in those things with which the senses
have to do. For what is poorer than to be susceptible of endless diminution? and what more
truly rich than to increase as much as you will, to go whither you will, to return when you
will and as far as you will, and to have as the object of your love that which is large and
cannot be made less? For whoever understands these numbers loves nothing so much as
the unit; and no wonder, seeing that it is through it that all the other numbers can be loved
by him. But to return: Why is the world the size that it is, seeing that it might have been
greater or less? I do not know: its dimensions are what they are, and I can go no further.
Again: Why is the world in the place it now occupies rather than in another? Here, too, it
is better not to put the question; for whatever the answer might be, other questions would
still remain. This one thing greatly perplexed me, that bodies could be infinitely subdivided.
To this perhaps an answer has been given, by setting over against it the converse property
of abstract number [viz. its susceptibility of infinite multiplication].
3. But stay: let us see what is that indefinable object1446 which is suggested to the mind.
This world with which our senses acquaint us is surely the image of some world which the
understanding apprehends. Now it is a strange phenomenon which we observe in the images
which mirrors reflect to us,—that however great the mirrors be, they do not make the images
1445 Had Augustin been acquainted with the decimal notation, he would not have made this remark to
Alypius; for in the decimal scale, when the point is inserted, fractional parts go on diminishing according to the
number of cyphers between them and the point (e.g .001), precisely as the integers increase according to the
number of cyphers between them and the decimal point (e.g. 100.),—there being no limit to the descending
series on the right hand of the decimal point, any more than to the ascending series on the left hand of the same
point.
1446 Nescio quid.
516
To Nebridius