The Life of St. Antony
is included in the present collection partly on account of the
important influence it has exercised upon the development of the
ascetic life in the Church, partly and more especially on the ground of
its strong claim to rank as a work of Athanasius. If that claim were
undisputed, no apology would be needed for its presence in this volume.
If on the other hand its spurious and unhistorical character had been
finally demonstrated, its insertion would be open to just objections.
As it is, the question being still in dispute, although the balance of
qualified opinion is on the side of the Athanasian authorship, it is
well that the reader should have the work before him and judge for
himself. To assist his judgment, it will be attempted in the following
paragraphs to state the main reasons on either side. In doing so, I can
honestly disclaim any bias for or against the Vita, or
monasticism. Monasticism, with all its good and evil, is a great
outgrowth of human life and instinct, a great fact in the history of
the Christian religion; and whether its origin is to be put fifty years
earlier or later (for that is the net value of the question at issue)
is a somewhat small point relatively to the great problems which it
offers to the theologian, the historian, and the moralist. But the
point is at any rate worthy of careful and dispassionate examination.
In attempting this, while holding no brief for either side, I may as
well at once state my opinion on the evidence, namely that, genuine as
are many of the difficulties which surround the question, the external
evidence for the Vita is too strong to allow us to set it aside
as spurious, and that in view of that evidence the attempts to give a
positive account of the book as a spurious composition have failed.