It is certain that by the “Tome of the
Westerns” a dogmatic work of the Western bishops is to be
understood, and the only question is which Tome of the Westerns is here
meant. Several—for instance, the Greek commentators,
Balsamon and Zonaras, and the spokesman of the Latins at the Synod of
Florence in 1439 (Archbishop Andrew of Rhodes)—understood by it
the decrees of the Synod of Sardica; but it seems to me that
this canon undoubtedly indicates
that the Tome of the Westerns also mentioned the condition of the
Antiochian Church, and the division into two parties of the orthodox of
that place—the Meletian schism. Now, as this was not
mentioned, nay, could not have been, at the Synod of Sardica—for
this schism at Antioch only broke out seventeen years later—some
other document of the Latins must certainly be meant. But we know
that Pope Damasus, and the synod assembled by him in 369, addressed a
Tome to the Orientals, of which fragments are still preserved, and that
nine years later, in 379, a great synod at Antioch of one hundred and
forty-six orthodox Oriental bishops, under Meletius, accepted and
signed this Tome, and at the same time sought to put a stop to the
Meletian schism. Soon afterwards, in 380, Pope Damasus and his
fourth Roman Synod again sent a treatise on the faith, of which we
still possess a portion, containing anathemas, to the Orientals,
especially to Bishop Paul of Antioch, head of the Eustathians of that
city. Under these circumstances, we are justified in referring
the expression “the tome of the Westerns” either to the
Roman treatise of 369 or to that of 380, and I am disposed to give the
preference to the former, for the following reasons:—