one of these two qualities; but that which is to be found neither in the category of good nor
that of bad is in no category at all; for this antithesis between good and bad is an opposition
that admits no middle; and neither will come to him who has not made a beginning with
either of them. What therefore falls under neither of these heads may be said not even to
have existed. But if some one says that such a life does not only exist, but exists as one of
the good ones, and that God gives, though He does not repay, what is good to such, we may
ask what sort of reason he advances for this partiality; how is justice apparent in such a view;
how will he prove his idea in concordance with the utterances in the Gospels? There (the
Master) says, the acquisition of the Kingdom comes to those who are deemed worthy of it,
as a matter of exchange. “When ye have done such and such things, then it is right that ye
get the Kingdom as a reward.” But in this case there is no act of doing or of willing before-
hand, and so what occasion is there for saying that these will receive from God any expected
recompense? If one unreservedly accepts a statement such as that, to the effect that any so
passing into life will necessarily be classed amongst the good, it will dawn upon him then
that not partaking in life at all will be a happier state than living, seeing that in the one case
the enjoyment of good is placed beyond a doubt even with barbarian parentage, or a con-
ception from a union not legitimate; but he who has lived the span ordinarily possible to
Nature gets the pollution of evil necessarily mingled more or less with his life, or, if he is to
be quite outside this contagion, it will be at the price of much painful effort. For virtue is
achieved by its seekers not without a struggle; nor is abstinence from the paths of pleasure
a painless process to human nature. So that one of two probations must be the inevitable
fate of him who has had the longer lease of life; either to combat here on Virtue’s toilsome
field, or to suffer there the painful recompense of a life of evil. But in the case of infants
prematurely dying there is nothing of that sort; but they pass to the blessed lot at once, if
those who take this view of the matter speak true. It follows also necessarily from this that
a state of unreason is preferable to having reason, and virtue will thereby be revealed as of
no value: if he who has never possessed it suffers no loss, so, as regards the enjoyment of
blessedness, the labour to acquire it will be useless folly; the unthinking condition will be
the one that comes out best from God’s judgment. For these and such-like reasons you bid
me sift the matter, with a view to our getting, by dint of a closely-reasoned inquiry, some
firm ground on which to rest our thoughts about it.
For my part, in view of the difficulties of the subject proposed, I think the exclamation
of the Apostle very suitable to the present case, just as he uttered it over unfathomable
questions: “O the depth of the riches both of the wisdom and knowledge of God! how un-
searchable are His judgments, and His ways past finding out! For who hath known the mind
of the Lord1541?” But seeing on the other hand that that Apostle declares it to be a peculiarity
1541 Rom. xi. 33, 34.
694
On Infants' Early Deaths.