b. Modern discussions. Since the
Reformation the general tendency of protestant writers has been to
discredit, of Roman Catholics to maintain the authority of the Vita. To
the former class belong the Magdeburg Centuriators, Rivet, Basnage,
Casimir Oudin; to the latter, Bellarmin, Noel Alexandre, and above all
Montfaucon in the Benedictine edition of Athanasius (especially in the
Vita Athanasii, Animadversio II. in Vitam et Scripta S.A., and
the Monitum in Antonii Vitam, which latter may still claim the
first rank in critical discussions of the problem). We may add, as more
or less unbiassed defenders of the Vita, Cave (Hist. Lit.
i. 193), and Tillemont (Mem. vol. vii.). All the above belong to
the period before 1750. In more recent times the attack has been led by
Weingarten (Ursprung des Mönchtums in nachkonst. zeitalter,
reprinted in 1877 from Zeitschrift für K.G. 1876, and in
Herzog, vol. x. pp. 758 sqq.), followed by Gass (in Ztsch. K.G.
II. 274), and Gwatkin (Studies, &c. pp. 98–103).
Israel, in Zeitsch. Wiss. Theol. 1880, p. 130, &c.,
characterises Weingarten’s attack on the Vita as
‘too bold.’ Keim (Aus dem Urchr. 207 sqq.) and
Hilgenfeld (in Zeitsch. f. Wiss. Theol. 1878) put the book in
the lifetime of Ath. without absolutely pronouncing for him as the
author, while Hase (J. Prot. Th. 1880), Harnack (especially in
Th. Ltz. xi. 391, see also
‘Das Mönchtum’ u.s.w., Giessen, 1886),
Möller, Lehrb. der K.G. i. 372, and Eichhorn
(‘Athanasii de vita ascetica testimonia,’ Halle,
1886, the most convincing discussion of recent date, and indispensable)
decide without hesitation in its favour. The discussion of Bornemann
(In investigando monachatus origine, quibus de causis ratio habenda
sit Origenis, Leipzig, 1885) may also be mentioned as bearing on
the general subject; also the articles ‘Monastery,’
‘Cœnobium,’ and ‘Hermits’ in D. C. A. The
article ‘Antony’ in D. C. B. passes over the question
without discussion, excepting the trite, but untenable, statement that
the Vita ‘is probably interpolated.’ Farrar (Lives of
the Fathers, and Contemp. Review, Nov. 1887) follows
Gwatkin. Picturesque representations of Antony (from the Vita)
in Kingsley’s Hermits and Newman’s Historical
Sketches, vol. 2.