We look in vain for any statement of principle on
the part of Athanasius to reduce this confusion to order. The classical
passage in his writings is the letter he has preserved from Julius of
Rome to the Eastern bishops (Apol. c. Ar. 20–35). The
Easterns insist strongly on the authority of Councils, in the interests
of their deposition of Athanasius, &c., at Tyre. Julius can only
reply by invoking an old-established custom of the Church, ratified, he
says, at Nicæa (Can. 5?), that the decisions of one Council
may be revised by another; a process which leads to no finality. The
Sardican canons of three years later drew up, for judicial purposes
only, a system of procedure, devolving on Julius (or possibly on the
Roman bishop for the time being) the duty of deciding, upon the
initiative of the parties concerned, whether in the case of a deposed
bishop a new trial of the case was desirable, and permitting him to
take part in such new trial by his deputies. But Athanasius never
alludes to any such procedure, nor to the canons in question. (Compare
above, pp. xlii., xlvi.).