Anything more perfect than these precious volumes it
would be hard to conceive of, and while of course they contain the
errors of chronology et cetera of their age, yet their general
accuracy and marvellous completeness leave them even to-day as the
greatest of the great, although the later edition of Hardouin is more
often used by English and American scholars, and is the one quoted by
Pope Benedict XIV. in his famous work De Synodo
Diæcesana. Hardouin’s edition did certainly
correct many of the faults of Labbe and Cossart, yet had itself many
faults and defects which are pointed out by Salmon Salmon, l. c., pp.
315–331, 786–831. in
a long list, although he fully acknowledges the value of
Hardouin’s improvements and additions. Perhaps, not
unnaturally, as a Professor at the Sorbonne, he preferred Labbe and
Cossart. It may not be amiss to add that Hardouin was very
anti-Gallican and ultramontane.