Elucidations.
————————————
I.
(Such as have lapsed, cap. vii. p. 660.)
The penitential system of the Primitive days, referred
to in our author, began to be changed when less public confessions were
authorized, on account of the scandals which publicity generated.
Changes were as follows:
1. A grave presbyter was appointed to receive and
examine voluntary penitents as the Penitentiary of a diocese, and to
suspend or reconcile them with due solemnities—
circa
a.d.
250.
2. This plan also became encumbered with
difficulties and was abolished in the East,
circa
a.d.
400.
3. A discipline similar to that of the Anglican Church
(which is but loosely maintained therein) succeeded, under St.
Chrysostom; who frequently maintains the sufficiency of confession
according to
Matt. vi.
6
. A Gallican
author
8538
says—“this is the period regarded by historians as the most
brilliant in Church history. At the close of the fourth century, in the
great churches of the Orient,
sixty thousand Christians
received
the Eucharistic communion, in one day,
in both kinds
, with no
other than their private confessions to Almighty God. The
scandalous evil-liver alone was repelled from the Eucharistic
Table.” This continued till
circa
a.d.
700.
4. Particular, but voluntary confessions
were now made in the East and West, but with widely various acceptance
under local systems of discipline. The absolutions were
precatory
: “may God absolve Thee.” This lasted, even
in the West, till the compulsory system of the Lateran Council,
a.d.
1215.
5. Since this date, so far as the West is
concerned, the whole system of corrupt casuistry and enforced
confession adopted in the West has utterly destroyed the Primitive
doctrine and discipline as to sin and its remedy wherever it prevails.
In the East, private confession exists in a system wholly different and
one which maintains the Primitive Theology and the Scriptural
principle. (1) It is voluntary; (2) it is free from the corrupt system
of the casuists; (3) it distinguishes between Ecclesiastical Absolution
and that of Him who alone “seeth in secret;” (4) it admits
no compromise with
attrition
, but exacts the contrite
heart
and the firm resolve
to go and sin no more, and (5) finally, it employs a most guarded and
Evangelical formula of remission, of which see Elucidation IV.
II.
(The last hope, cap. vii. p. 662.)
How absolutely the Lateran Council has overthrown
the Primitive discipline is here made manifest. The spirit of the
latter is expressed by our author in language which almost prompts to
despair. It makes sin “exceeding sinful” and even
Ecclesiastical forgiveness the reverse of easy. The Lateran
System of enforced Confession makes sin easy and restoration to a
sinless state equally so: a perpetual resort to the confessor being the
only condition for evil living, and a chronic state of pardon and
peace. But, let the Greek Church be heard in this matter, rather
than an Anglican Catholic. I refer to Macarius, Bishop of Vinnitza and
Rector of the Theological Academy of St. Petersburg, as
follows:
8539
“It is
requisite (for the effective reception of Absolution) at least
according to the teaching of the Orthodox Church of the Orient, that
the following conditions be observed: (1) Contrition for sins, is in
the very nature of Penitence, indispensable; (2), consequently, there
must be a firm resolution to reform the life; (3) also, faith in Christ
and hope in his mercy, with (4) auricular confession before the
priest.” He allows that this latter condition was not
primitive
, but was a
maternal concession
to penitents of
later date: this, however, is voluntary, and of a widely different form
from that of the Latin, as will appear below in Elucidation
IV.
Now, he contrasts with this the system of Rome,
and condemns it, on overwhelming considerations. 1. It makes
penances compensations
8540
or
“satisfaction,” offered for sins to divine Justice, this
(he says) “is in contradiction with the Christian doctrine of
justification, the Scripture teaching one full and entire satisfaction
for the sins of the whole human race, once for all presented by our
Lord Jesus Christ. This doctrine is equally in conflict with the entire
teaching of the Primitive Church.”
2. It introduces a false system of
indulgences
, as the consequence of its false
premisses.
3. He demonstrates the insufficiency of
attrition
, which respects the fear of punishment, and not sin
itself. But the Council of Trent affirms the sufficiency of
attrition
, and permits the confessor to absolve the
attrite. Needless to say, the masses accept this wide gate and
broad way to salvation rather than the strait gate and narrow way of
hating sin and reforming the life, in obedience to the
Gospel.
III.
(Among brethren, cap. x., p. 662.)
A controversial writer has lately complained that
Bp. Kaye speaks of the
public confession
treated of by our
author in this work, and adds—“Tertullian nowhere used the
word
public
.” The answer is that he speaks of the
discipline of
Exomologesis
, which was, in
its own nature, as public as preaching. A Gallican writer, less
inclined to Jesuitism in the use of words, says frankly: “When
one studies this question, with the documents before his eyes, it is
impossible not to confess that the Primitive discipline of the Church
exhibits not a vestige of the auricular confession afterwards
introduced.” See Irenæus,
Adv. Hæres
. Vol. I. p.
335, this Series. The Lii. of the canons called Apostolical, reflects a
very simple view of the matter, in these words: “If any Bishop or
Presbyter will not receive one who
turns from
his sins, but
casts him out, let him be deposed: for he grieves Christ, who said,
There shall be joy in heaven over one sinner that repenteth.” The
ascetic spirit of our author seems at war with that of this
Canon.
IV.
(Exomologesis, cap. xii., p. 663.)
To this day, in the Oriental Churches, the examination
of the presbyter who hears the voluntary confession of penitents, is
often very primitive in its forms and confined to general inquiries
under the Decalogue. The Casuistry of (Dens and Liguori) the Western
Schemata Practica
has not defiled our Eastern brethren to any
great extent.
In the office
8541
(
᾽Ακολουθία
τῶν
ἐξομολουγουμένων
) we have a simple and beautiful form of prayer and supplication in
which the following is the formula of Absolution: “My Spiritual
child, who hast confessed to my humility, I, unworthy and a sinner,
have not the power to forgive sins on Earth
; God only can: and
through that Divine voice which came to the Apostles, after the
Resurrection of our Lord Jesus Christ, saying—‘Whosoever
sins, etc.,’ we, therein confiding, say—Whatsoever thou
hast confessed to my extreme humility, and whatsoever thou hast
omitted to say
, either through ignorance or forgetfulness,
God forgive thee
in this present world and in that which is to
come.”
The plural (
We
therein confiding) is
significant and a token of Primitive doctrine:
i.e.
of
confession before the whole Church, (
2 Cor. ii. 10
): and note the precatory
form—“God forgive thee.” The perilous form
Ego te
absolvo
is not Catholic: it dates from the thirteenth century and
is used in the West only. It is not wholly dropped from the Anglican
Office, but has been omitted from the American Prayer-Book.
8538
Le Confesseur, par
L’Abbé * * * p. 15, Brussels 1866.
8539
Theol. Dogmat.
Orthodoxe
, pp. 529–541, etc.
8540
Couc. Trident.
Sess. xiv. cap. 8.
8541
The Great Euchologion,
p. 220, Venice, 1851.