§4. Then, having shown that Eunomius’ calumny against the great Basil, that he called
the Only-begotten “Ungenerate,” is false, and having again with much ingenuity discussed
the eternity, being, and endlessness of the Only-begotten, and the creation of light and of
darkness, he concludes the book.
With regard to his attempting to show that we say the Only-begotten God is ungenerate,
it is as though he should say that we actually define the Father to be begotten: for either
217
statement is of the same absurdity, or rather of the same blasphemous character. If, therefore,
he has made up his mind to slander us, let him add the other charge as well, and spare
nothing by which it may be in his power more violently to exasperate his hearers against
us. But if one of these charges is withheld because its calumnious nature is apparent, why
is the other made? For it is just the same thing, as we have said, so far as the impiety goes,
to call the Son ungenerate and to call the Father generated. Now if any such phrase can be
found in our writings, in which the Son is spoken of as ungenerate, we shall give the final
vote against ourselves: but if he is fabricating false charges and calumnies at his pleasure,
making any fictitious statement he pleases to slander our doctrines, this fact may serve with
sensible men for an evidence of our orthodoxy, that while truth itself fights on our side, he
brings forward a lie to accuse our doctrine and makes up an indictment for unorthodoxy
that has no relation to our statements. To these charges, however, we can give a concise
answer. As we judge that man accursed who says that the Only-begotten God is ungenerate,
let him in turn anathematize the man who lays it down that He who was in the beginning
“once was not.” For by such a method it will be shown who brings his charges truly, and
who calumniously. But if we deny his accusations, if, when we speak of a Father, we under-
stand as implied in that word a Son also, and if, when we use the name “Son,” we declare
that He really is what He is called, being shed forth by generation from the ungenerate Light,
how can the calumny of those who persist that we say the Only-begotten is ungenerate fail
to be manifest? Yet we shall not, because we say that He exists by generation, therefore admit
that He “once was not.” For every one knows that the contradiction between “being” and
“not being” is immediate, so that the affirmation of one of these terms is absolutely the de-
struction of the other, and that, just as “being” is the same in regard to every time at which
any of the things that “are” is supposed to have its existence (for the sky, and stars, and sun,
and the rest of the things that “are,” are not more in a state of being now than they were
yesterday, or the day before, or at any previous time), so the meaning of “not being” expresses
non-existence equally at every time, whether one speaks of it in reference to what is earlier
or to what is later. For any of the things that do not exist920 is no more in a state of “not
920 Reading τῶν μὴ ὑφεστώτων, as the sense seems to require, unless we connect τῶν ὑφεστώτων with οὐκ
ἔστιν. In this case the sense will be practically the same, but the sentence will be extremely involved. The point
which S. Gregory desires to enforce is that “not being,” or “non-existence,” is one and the same thing, whether
Then, having shown that Eunomius' calumny against the great Basil, that he called the Only-begotten “Ungenerate,” is false, and having again with much ingenuity discussed the eternity, being, and endlessness of the Only-begotten, and the creation of light and of darkness, he concludes the book.
416
Then, having shown that Eunomius' calumny against the great Basil, that…