Having accepted then these men’s
interpretation and defence of their language, we made enquiry of those
blamed by them for speaking of One Subsistence, whether they use the
expression in the sense of Sabellius, to the negation of the Son and the Holy Spirit, or as
though the Son were non-substantial, or the Holy Spirit impersonal ἀνουσίου,
ἀνυποστάτου, the words are rendered ‘unessential’ and
‘not subsisting’ in another connection, supr. p.
434, &c.. But they in their turn assured us that they
neither meant this nor had ever held it, but ‘we use the word
Subsistence thinking it the same thing to say Subsistence or
Essence;’ ‘But we hold that there is One, because the Son
is of the Essence of the Father, and because of the identity of nature.
For we believe that there is one Godhead, and that it has one nature,
and not that there is one nature of the Father, from which that of the
Son and of the Holy Spirit are distinct.’ Well, thereupon they
who had been blamed for saying there were three Subsistences agreed
with the others, while those who had spoken of One Essence, also
confessed the doctrine of the former as interpreted by them. And by
both sides Arius was anathematised as an adversary of Christ, and
Sabellius, and Paul of Samosata, as impious men, and Valentinus and
Basilides as aliens from the truth, and Manichæus as an inventor
of mischief. And all, by God’s grace, and after the above
explanations, agree together that the faith confessed by the fathers at
Nicæa is better than the said phrases, and that for the future
they would prefer to be content to use its language.