The origin of the controversy is obscure. It
certainly must be placed as early as 318 or 319, to leave sufficient
time before the final deposition of Arius in the council of 321
(infr. p. 234). We are told that Arius, a native of Libya, had
settled in Alexandria soon after the origin of the Meletian schism, and
had from motives of ambition sided at first with Meletius, then with
Peter, who ordained him deacon, but afterwards was compelled to depose
him (Epiph. Hær. 69, Sozom. i. 15). He became reconciled to
Achillas, who raised him to the presbyterate. Disappointed of the
bishopric at the election of Alexander, he nurtured a private grudge
(Thdt. H. E. i. 2), which eventually culminated in opposition to
his teaching. These tales deserve little credit: they are unsupported
by Athanasius, and bear every trace of invention ex post facto.
That Arius was a vain person we see from his Thalia (infr. p.
308): but he certainly possessed claims to personal respect, and we
find him not only in charge of the urban parish of Baucalis, but
entrusted with the duties of a professor of scriptural exegesis. There
is in fact no necessity to seek for personal motives to explain the
dispute. The Arian problem was one which the Church was unable to
avoid. Not until every alternative had been tried and rejected was the
final theological expression of her faith possible. Two great streams
of theological influence had run their course in the third century: the
subordinationist theology of Origen at Alexandria, the Monarchian
theology of the West and of Asia which had found a logical expression
in Paul of Samosata. Both streams had met in Lucian the martyr, at
Antioch, and in Arius, the pupil of Lucian, produced a result which
combined elements of both (see below, §3 (2) a). According to some
authorities Arius was the aggressor. He challenged some theological
statements of Alexander as Sabellian, urging in opposition to them that
if the Son were truly a Son He must have had a beginning, and that
there had been therefore a time when He did not exist. According to others
(Constantine in Eus. Vit. ii. 69) Alexander had demanded of his
presbyters an explanation of some passage of Scripture which had led
Arius to broach his heresy. At any rate the attitude of Alexander was
at first conciliatory. Himself an Origenist, he was willing to give
Arius a fair hearing (Sozom. ubi supra). But the latter was
impracticable. He began to canvass for support, and his doctrine was
widely accepted. Among his first partisans were a number of lay people
and virgins, five presbyters of Alexandria, six deacons, including
Euzoius, afterwards Arian bishop at Antioch (a.d. 361), and the Libyan bishops Secundus of Ptolemais in
Pentapolis (see p. 226) and Theonas of Marmarica (see p. 70). A letter
was addressed to Arius and his friends by Alexander, and signed by the
clergy of Alexandria, but without result. A synod was now called
(infr. p. 70, Socr. i. 6) of the bishops of Egypt and
Libya, and Arius and his allies deposed. Even this did not check the
movement. In Egypt two presbyters and four deacons of the Mareotis, one
of the former being Pistus, a later Arian bishop of Alexandria,
declared for Arius; while abroad he was in correspondence with
influential bishops who cordially promised their support. Conspicuous
among the latter was a man of whom we shall hear much in the earlier
treatises of this volume, Eusebius, bishop of Berytus, who had
recently, against the older custom of the Church (p. 103, note 6), but
in accordance with what has ever since been general in the case of
important sees, been translated to the imperial city of Nicomedia. High
in the favour, perhaps related to the family, of Constantine, possessed
of theological training and practical ability, this remarkable man was
for nearly a quarter of a century the head and centre of the Arian
cause. (For his character and history, see the excellent article in
D.C.B. ii. 360–367.) He had been a fellow-pupil of Arius in the
school of Lucian, and fully shared his opinions (his letter to Paulinus
of Tyre, Thdt. H. E. i. 6). The letter addressed to him by Arius
(ib. 5) is one of our most important Arian monuments. Arius claims the
sympathy of Eusebius of Cæsarea and other leading bishops, in fact
of all the East excepting Macarius of Jerusalem and two others,
‘heretical and untutored persons.’ Eusebius responded with
zeal to the appeal of his ‘fellow-Lucianist.’ While
Alexander was indefatigable in writing to warn the bishops everywhere
against Arius (who had now left Alexandria to seek foreign support,
first in Palestine, then at Nicomedia), and in particular addressed a
long letter to Alexander, bishop of Byzantium (Thdt. H. E. i.
4), Eusebius called a council at Nicomedia, which issued letters in
favour of Arius to many bishops, and urged Alexander himself to receive
him to communion. Meanwhile a fresh complication had appeared in Egypt.
Colluthus, whose name stands first among the signatures to the
memorandum (to be mentioned presently) of the deposition of Arius,
impatient it would seem at the moderation of Alexander, founded a
schism of his own, and although merely a presbyter, took upon himself
to ordain. In Egypt and abroad confusion reigned: parties formed in
every city, bishops, to adopt the simile of Eusebius (Vit.
Const.), collided like the fabled Symplegades, the most sacred of
subjects were bandied about in the mouths of the populace, Christian
and heathen.