Chapter 35.—67. Castus of Sicca1723 said: He who presumes to follow custom in despite
of truth is either envious and evilly disposed towards the brethren to whom the truth is re-
vealed, or else he is ungrateful towards God, by whose inspiration His Church is instruc-
ted."1724
68. If this man proved that those who differed from him, and held the view that has
since been held by the whole world under the sanction of a Christian Council, were following
custom so as to despise truth, we should have reason for fearing these words; but seeing that
this custom is found both to have had its origin in truth and to have been confirmed by
truth, we have nothing to fear in this judgment. And yet, if they were envious or evilly dis-
posed towards the brethren, or ungrateful towards God, see with what kind of men they
were willing to hold communion; see what kind of men, holding different opinions from
their own, they treated as Cyprian enjoined them at the first, not removing them from the
right of communion; see by what kind of men they were not polluted in the preservation of
unity; see how greatly the bond of peace was to be loved; see what views they hold who bring
charges against us, founded on the Council of bishops, their predecessors, whose example
they do not imitate, and by whose example, when the rights of the case are considered, they
are condemned. If it was the custom, as this judgment bears witness, that heretics coming
to the Church should be received with the baptism which they already had, either this was
done rightly, or the evil do not pollute the good in unity. If it was rightly done, why do they
accuse the world because they are so received? But if the evil do not pollute the good in
unity, how do they defend themselves against the charge of sacrilegious separation?
1723 Sicca was in ecclesiastical province of Zeugitana. This is certainly not the Castus of Cypr. de Laps. c.
xiii.
1724 Conc. Carth. sec. 28.
Chapter 35
907
Chapter 35