“When they had set forth
this formulary, we did not leave without examination that passage in
which it is said that the Son is of the substance of the Father, and
consubstantial with the Father. Questions and arguments thence arose,
and the meaning of the terms was exactly tested. Accordingly they were
led to confess that the word consubstantial signifies that the Son is
of the Father, but not as being a part of the Father. We deemed it
right to receive this opinion; for that is sound doctrine which teaches
that the Son is of the Father, but not part of His substance. From the
love of peace, and lest we should fall from the true belief, we also
accept this view, neither do we reject the term
‘consubstantial.’ For the same reason we admitted the
expression, ‘begotten, but not made;’ for they alleged that
the word ‘made’ applies generally to all things which were
created by the Son, to which the Son is in no respect similar; and that
consequently He is not a created thing, like the things made by Him,
but is of a substance superior to all created objects. The Holy
Scriptures teach Him to be begotten of the Father, by a mode of
generation which is incomprehensible and inexplicable to all created
beings. So also the term ‘of one substance with the
Father,’ when investigated, was accepted not in accordance with
bodily relations or similarity to mortal beings. For it was also shown
that it does not either imply division of substance, nor abscission,
nor any modification or change or diminution in the power of the
Father, all of which are alien from the nature of the unbegotten
Father. It was concluded that the expression ‘being of one
substance with the Father,’ implies that the Son of God does
not resemble, in any one respect, the creatures which He has made; but
that to the Father alone, who begat Him, He is in all points perfectly
like: for He is of the essence and of the substance ὑποστάσεως
and οὐσίας of none save of the Father. This
interpretation having been given of the doctrine, it appeared right to
us to assent to it, especially as we were aware that of the ancients
some learned and celebrated bishops and writers have used the term
‘consubstantial’ with respect to the divinity of the Father
and of the Son.