Chapter 1.—1. How much the arguments make for us, that is, for catholic peace, which
the party of Donatus profess to bring forward against us from the authority of the blessed
Cyprian, and how much they prove against those who bring them forward, it is my intention,
with the help of God, to show in the ensuing book. If, therefore, in the course of my argu-
ment, I am obliged to repeat what I have already said in other treatises (although I will do
so as little as I can,) yet this ought not to be objected to by those who have already read them
and agree with them; since it is not only right that those things which are necessary for in-
struction should be frequently instilled into men of dull intelligence, but even in the case of
those who are endowed with larger understanding, it contributes very much both to make
their learning easier and their powers of teaching readier, where the same points are handled
and discussed in many various ways. For I know how much it discourages a reader, when
he comes upon any knotty question in the book which he has in hand, to find himself
presently referred for its solution to another which he happens not to have. Wherefore, if
I am compelled, by the urgency of the present questions, to repeat what I have already said
in other books, I would seek forgiveness from those who know those books already, that
those who are ignorant may have their difficulties removed; for it is better to give to one
who has already, than to abstain from satisfying any one who is in want.
2. What, then, do they venture to say, when their mouth is closed1209 by the force of
truth, with which they will not agree? "Cyprian," say they, "whose great merits and vast
learning we all know, decreed in a Council,1210 with many of his fellow-bishops contributing
their several opinions, that all heretics and schismatics, that is, all who are severed from the
communion of the one Church, are without baptism; and therefore, whosoever has joined
the communion of the Church after being baptized by them must be baptized in the Church."
The authority of Cyprian does not alarm me, because I am reassured by his humility. We
know, indeed, the great merit of the bishop and martyr Cyprian; but is it in any way greater
than that of the apostle and martyr Peter, of whom the said Cyprian speaks as follows in his
epistle to Quintus? "For neither did Peter, whom the Lord chose first, and on whom He
built His Church,1211 when Paul afterwards disputed with him about circumcision, claim
or assume anything insolently and arrogantly to himself, so as to say that he held the primacy,
and should rather be obeyed of those who were late and newly come. Nor did he despise
Paul because he had before been a persecutor of the Church, but he admitted the counsel
of truth, and readily assented to the legitimate grounds which Paul maintained; giving us
1209 Præfocantur.
1210 The Council of Carthage, A.D. 256, in which eighty-seven African bishops declared in favor of rebap-
tizing heretics. The opinions of the bishops are quoted and answered by Augustin, one by one, in Books vi and
vii.
1211 Matt. xvi. 18.
Chapter 1
729
Chapter 1