The disjointed incoherencies
which follow next, I think it well to pass over, not because they give
no handle at all to censure, but because their language is such as
might be used by the devout, if detached from its malignant context. If
he does here and there use some expressions favourable to devotion it
is just held out as a bait to simple souls, to the end that the hook of
impiety may be swallowed along with it. For after employing such
language as a member of the Church might use, he subjoins,
“Obedient with regard to the creation and production of all
things that are, obedient with regard to every ministration, not having
by His obedience attained Sonship or Godhead, but, as a consequence of
being Son and being generated as the Only-begotten God, showing Himself
obedient in words, obedient in acts.” Yet who of those who are
conversant with the oracles of God does not know with regard to what
point of time it was said of Him by the mighty Paul, (and that once for
all), that He “became obedient Phil. ii. 8.”? For it
was when He came in the form of a servant to accomplish the mystery of
redemption by the cross, Who had emptied Himself, Who humbled Himself
by assuming the likeness and fashion of a man, being found as man in
man’s lowly nature—then, I say, it was that He became
obedient, even He Who “took our infirmities and bare our
sicknesses Cf.
S. Matt. viii. 17.,” healing the disobedience of men
by His own obedience, that by His stripes He might heal our wound, and
by His own death do away with the common death of all men,—then
it was that for our sakes He was made obedient, even as He became
“sin 2 Cor. v. 21.” and “a curse Gal. iii. 13.” by reason of the dispensation on our
behalf, not being so by nature, but becoming so in His love for man.
But by what sacred utterance was He ever taught His list of so many
obediences? Nay, on the contrary every inspired Scripture attests His
independent and sovereign power, saying, “He spake the word and
they were made: He commanded and they were created Ps. cxlviii.
5.”:—for it is plain that the
Psalmist says this concerning Him Who upholds “all things by the
word of His power Heb. i. 3.,” Whose
authority, by the sole impulse of His will, framed every existence and
nature, and all things in the creation apprehended by reason or by
sight. Whence, then, was Eunomius moved to ascribe in such manifold
wise to the King of the universe the attribute of obedience, speaking
of Him as “obedient with regard to all the work of creation,
obedient with regard to every ministration, obedient in words and in
acts”? Yet it is plain to every one, that he alone is obedient to
another in acts and words, who has not yet perfectly achieved in
himself the condition of accurate working or unexceptionable speech,
but keeping his eye ever on his teacher and guide, is trained by his
suggestions to exact propriety in deed and word. But to think that
Wisdom needs a master and teacher to guide aright Its attempts at
imitation, is the dream of Eunomius’ fancy, and of his alone. And
concerning the Father he says, that He is faithful in words and
faithful in works, while of the Son he does not assert faithfulness in
word and deed, but only obedience and not faithfulness, so that his
profanity extends impartially through all his statements. But it is
perhaps right to pass in silence over the inconsiderate folly of the
assertion interposed between those last mentioned, lest some
unreflecting persons should laugh at its absurdity when they ought
rather to weep over the perdition of their souls, than laugh at the
folly of their words. For this wise and wary theologian says that He
did not attain to being a Son as the result of His obedience! Mark his
penetration! with what cogent force does he lay it down for us that He
was not first obedient and afterwards a Son, and that we ought not to
think that His obedience was prior to His generation! Now if he had not
added this defining clause, who without it would have been sufficiently
silly and idiotic to fancy that His generation was bestowed on Him by His
Father, as a reward of the obedience of Him Who before His generation
had showed due subjection and obedience? But that no one may too
readily extract matter for laughter from these remarks, let each
consider that even the folly of the words has in it something worthy of
tears. For what he intends to establish by these observations is
something of this kind, that His obedience is part of His nature, so
that not even if He willed it would it be possible for Him not to be
obedient.