ates, forsooth, the Son from the Divine Nature, when he says that neither is any generated
thing spoken of as “ungenerate,” nor is God called “Son” or “generate,” and manifestly reveals
by this contradistinction the horrid character of his blasphemy. For when he has distinguished
the “things that have come into being” from the “ungenerate,” he goes on to say, in that
antistrophal induction of his, that it is impossible to call (not the “unbegotten,” but) “God,”
“Son” or “generate,” trying by these words to show that which is not ungenerate is not God,
and that the Only-begotten God is, by the fact of being begotten, as far removed from being
God as the ungenerate is from being generated in fact or in name. For it is not in ignorance
of the consequence of his argument that he makes an inversion of the terms employed thus
inharmonious and incongruous: it is in his assault on the doctrine of orthodoxy that he
opposes “the Godhead” to “the generate”—and this is the point he tries to establish by his
words, that that which is not ungenerate is not God. What was the true sequence of his ar-
gument? that having said “no generated thing is ungenerate,” he should proceed with the
inference, “nor, if anything is naturally ungenerate, can it be generate.” Such a statement at
once contains truth and avoids blasphemy. But now by his premise that no generated thing
is ungenerate, and his inference that God is not generated, he clearly shuts out the Only-
begotten God from being God, laying down that because He is not ungenerate, neither is
He God. Do we then need any further proofs to expose this monstrous blasphemy? Is not
this enough by itself to serve for a record against the adversary of Christ, who by the argu-
ments cited maintains that the Word, Who in the beginning was God, is not God? What
need is there to engage further with such men as this? For we do not entangle ourselves in
controversy with those who busy themselves with idols and with the blood that is shed upon
their altars, not that we acquiesce in the destruction of those who are besotted about idols,
but because their disease is too strong for our treatment. Thus, just as the fact itself declares
idolatry, and the evil that men do boldly and arrogantly anticipates the reproach of those
196
who accuse it, so here too I think that the advocates of orthodoxy should keep silence towards
one who openly proclaims his impiety to his own discredit, just as medicine also stands
powerless in the case of a cancerous complaint, because the disease is too strong for the art
to deal with.
375
He then declares that the close relation between names and things is immutable,…