that he conducted the war by Divine instruction, and the famous inscription on the triumphal
arch, “instinctu Divinitatis.” According to Augustine he was at the time of the petition of
the Donatists, “mindful of the hope which he maintained in Christ” (August. contra litt.
Petil. Bk. II. c. 92, p. 205).
The tales of his baptism at this time, or by Sylvester at all, are pure fables (cf. under The
Mythical Constantine), but it appears from antecedent probability, from testimony, and
from his early subsequent identification with the Christians that he became fairly convinced
at this time. His letters concerning the council at Arles, to be sure, have little direct evidence,
but enough to show that he regarded the Christian religion as the worship of that one supreme
God, and in them Hosius was already his trusted adviser. But in his letters to Chrestus (314)
he speaks of those who are “forgetful of their own salvation and the reverence due to the
most holy faith,” and if his letter to the bishops after the council at Arles—a letter full of
expressions like “Christ the Saviour,” “brethren beloved,” “I who myself await the judgment
of Christ,” “our Saviour”3044—be genuine, Constantine was well advanced in his commitment
432
in 314; but whether it is or not, the fact of his Christian advisers, of his laws in behalf of
Christians, and various substantial favors to them, his recognition of their God as his one
God, makes it almost idle to discuss the question. Was Constantine a Christian in 314? What
is a Christian? He seems to have been. The type was that of many a business-man church-
member of to-day—Christians, but neither over-well-instructed, nor dangerously zealous
in the exercise of his faith. It must be remembered that during these earlier years his confes-
sion of his faith and identification of himself with the Christians was conditioned by his
relation to the old religion. Such a change was a radical novelty. His position was not yet
secure. He had to use his utmost tact to keep all elements in hand. He was conditioned just
as a modern Christian emperor or president, a majority of whose political advisers and
subjects or electors are non-religious. He had great problems of political organization to
effect, and was immersed in these. The only matter of surprise is that he grew so rapidly.
There is no ground whatever for supposing that he dissembled to the end, or even at all. To
say that his retaining the title of pontifex maximus, or making concessions respecting the
old worship, or allowing soothsayers to be consulted, or even the postponement of his
baptism, indicate this, is critical absurdity in the face of evidence.3045 Testimony, both
3044 It seems to have been frequently accepted as such—in the collections of councils, by the editor of Optatus,
Ceillier, &c. It first appeared in the edition of Optatus, among the monuments relating to the Donatists gathered
by him. These monuments are from one single though tolerably ancient ms. and no source for this is quoted,
though the sources of others are given. In itself considered it is a surprise to find it at this stage of Constantine’s
life. Still, it is not unlike his later productions, and it is not impossible to think of its having been written in the
enthusiasm of a successfully ended enterprise. It would seem (unless there be some confirmatory study of the
letter, not now at hand) that a cautious criticism would base nothing on this letter alone.
3045 His saying before baptism is discussed in the V. C. 4. 2, notes.
1076
Religious Characteristics.