With regard to the question, so
much agitated, of the ᾽Αποκατάστασις, it may be said that not Gregory only but Basil and
Gregory Nazianzen also have felt the influence of their master in
theology, Origen. But it is due to the latter to say that though he
dwells much on the “all in all” and insists much more on
the sanctifying power of punishment than on the satisfaction owed to
Divine justice, yet no one could justly attribute to him, as a
doctrine, the view of a Universal Salvation. Still these Greek Fathers,
Origen and ‘the three great Cappadocians,’ equally showed a
disposition of mind that left little room for the discussions that were
soon to agitate the West. Their infinite hopes, their absolute
confidence in the goodness of God, who owes it to Himself to make
His work perfect, their profound faith in the promises and sacrifice of
Christ, as well as in the vivifying action of the Holy Spirit, make the
question of Predestination and Grace a very simple one with them. The
word Grace occurs as often in them as in Augustine: but they do not
make original sin a monstrous innovation requiring a remedy of a
peculiar and overwhelming intensity. Passion indeed seems to Gregory of
Nyssa himself one of the essential elements of the human soul. He
borrows from the naturalists many principles of distinction between
classes of souls and lives: he insists incessantly on the intimate
connexion between the physical growth and the development of the
reason, and on the correlation between the one and the other: and we
arrive at the conclusion that man in his eyes, as in Clement’s,
was not originally perfect, except in possibility; that being at once
reasoning and sentient he must perforce feel within himself the
struggle of reason and passion, and that it was inevitable that sin
should enter into the world: it was a consequence of his mixed nature.
This mixed nature of the first man was transmitted to his descendants.
Here, though he stands apart from Origen on the question of man’s
original perfection, he could not have accepted the whole Augustinian
scheme of original sin: and Grace as the remedy with him consists
rather in the purging this mixed nature, than in the introduction into
it of something absolutely foreign. The result, as with all the Greek
Fathers, will depend on the co-operation of the free agent in this
remedial work. Predestination and the ‘bad will’ are
excluded by the Possibility and the ‘free will’ of Origen
and Gregory.