20. When then was God without that which is
proper to Him? or how can a man consider that which is proper, as
foreign and alien in essence? for other things, according to the nature
of things originate, are without likeness in essence with the Maker;
but are external to Him, made by the Word at His grace and will, and
thus admit of ceasing to be, if it so pleases Him who made them This
was but the opposite aspect of the tenet of our Lord’s
consubstantiality or eternal generation. For if He came into being at
the will of God, by the same will He might cease to be; but if His
existence is unconditional and necessary, as God’s attributes
might be, then as He had no beginning, so can He have no end; for He is
in, and one with, the Father, who has neither beginning nor end. On the
question of the ‘will of God’ as it affects the doctrine,
vid. Orat. iii. §59, &c.; for such is the nature of things
originate §29, note.. But as to what is proper to the
Father’s essence (for this we have already found to be the Son),
what daring is it in irreligion to say that ‘This comes from
nothing,’ and that ‘It was not before generation,’
but was adventitious De
Decr. 22, note 9., and can at some
time cease to be again? Let a person only dwell upon this thought, and
he will discern how the perfection and the plenitude of the
Father’s essence is impaired by this heresy; however, he will see
its unseemliness still more clearly, if he considers that the Son is
the Image and Radiance of the Father, and Expression, and Truth. For
if, when Light exists, there be withal its Image, viz. Radiance, and, a
Subsistence existing, there be of it the entire Expression, and, a
Father existing, there be His Truth (viz. the Son); let them consider
what depths of irreligion they fall into, who make time the measure of
the Image and Form of the Godhead. For if the Son was not before His
generation, Truth was not always in God, which it were a sin to say;
for, since the Father was, there was ever in Him the Truth, which is
the Son, who says, ‘I am the Truth John xiv. 6..’ And the Subsistence existing, of
course there was forthwith its Expression and Image; for God’s
Image is not delineated from without Athan. argues from the very name Image for our Lord’s
eternity. An Image, to be really such, must be an expression from the
Original, not an external and detached imitation. vid. supr. note 10,
infr. §26. Hence S. Basil, ‘He is an Image not made with the
hand, or a work of art, but a living Image,’ &c. vid. also
contr. Eunom. ii. 16, 17. Epiph. Hær. 76. 3. Hilar.
Trin. vii. 41 fin. Origen observes that man, on the contrary, is
an example of an external or improper image of God. Periarch. i.
2. §6. It might have been more direct to have argued from the name
of Image to our Lord’s consubstantiality rather than eternity,
as, e.g. S. Gregory Naz. ‘He is Image as one in essence,
ὁμοούσιον,…for this is the nature of an image, to be a copy of
the archetype.’ Orat. 30. 20. vid. also de Decr.
§§20, 23, but for whatever reason Athan. avoids the
word ὁμοούσιον
in these Discourses. S. Chrys. on Col. i.
15., but God
Himself hath begotten it; in which seeing Himself, He has delight, as
the Son Himself says, ‘I was His delight Prov. viii.
30..’ When then did the Father not see
Himself in His own Image? or when had He not delight, that a man should
dare to say, ‘the Image is out of nothing,’ and ‘The
Father had not delight before the Image was originated?’ and how
should the Maker and Creator see Himself in a created and originated
essence? for such as is the Father, such must be the Image.