Immediately on receipt of your
holiness’s former letter I replied. About the present state of
affairs, it is impossible to entertain any good hope. I apprehend that
this is the beginning of the general apostasy. For when we see that
those who lament what was done as they say, by violence, at Ephesus,
show no signs of repentance, but abide by their unlawful deeds and are
building up a superstructure at once of injustice and of impiety; when
we see that the rest take no concerted action to deny their deeds and
do not refuse to hold communion with men who abide by their unlawful
action, what hope of good is it possible for us to entertain? Had they
been expressing their admiration of what has happened as though all had
been well and rightly done, it would only have been proper for them to
abide by what they themselves commend. But if, as they say, they are
lamenting what has been done and stating it to have been done by force
and violence, why in the world do they not repudiate what has been
unlawfully done? Why is the present, which lasts for such a little
time, preferred before what is sure to come to pass? Why in the world
do they openly lie and deny that any innovation has been introduced
into doctrine? On account of what murders and witchcrafts have I been
expelled? What adulteries did the man commit? What tombs did the man
violate? It is perfectly clear even to outsiders that it was for
doctrine that I and the rest were expelled. Why the Lord Domnus too,
because he would not accept “the Chapters” i.e. the twelve articles or chapters couched in the form of
anathema against the heads of Nestorian doctrine, appended to
Cyril’s third letter to Nestorius. was deposed by these excellent persons
who called them admirable and confessed that they abided by them. I had
read their propositions, and they rejected me as the head and front of
the heresy and expelled others for the same reason. It
has been pointed out before (Page 293) that at the Latrocinium Domnus
was compelled to yield his presidential seat as Patriarch of Antioch,
Dioscorus presiding, the Roman legate sitting second, and Juvenal of
Jerusalem third. “Cowed by the dictatorial spirit of Dioscorus
and unnerved by the outrageous violence of Barsumas and his band of
brutal monks he consented to revoke his former condemnation of
Eutyches.” “This cowardly act of submission was followed by
a still baser proof of weakness, the condemnation of the venerable
Flavian. Dioscorus having thus by sheer intimidation obtained his ends
revenged himself for their former opposition to his wishes upon those
whose cowardice had made them the instruments of his nefarious designs,
and proceeded to mete out to them the same measure they had dealt to
Flavian. Domnus was the last to be deposed. The charges alleged against
him were his reported approval of a Nestorian sermon preached before
him at Antioch by Theodoret, on the death of Cyril, and some
expressions in letters written by him to Dioscorus condemning the
obscure character of Cyril’s anathematisms.”
Canon Venables in Dic.
Chris. Biog. vol 1. p. 879.