Chapter 17.—What Defence is Made by Sound Faith Regarding God’s Unchangeable
Counsel and Will, Against the Reasonings of Those Who Hold that the Works of God are
Eternally Repeated in Revolving Cycles that Restore All Things as They Were.
Of this, too, I have no doubt, that before the first man was created, there never had been
a man at all, neither this same man himself recurring by I know not what cycles, and having
made I know not how many revolutions, nor any other of similar nature. From this belief
I am not frightened by philosophical arguments, among which that is reckoned the most
acute which is founded on the assertion that the infinite cannot be comprehended by any
mode of knowledge. Consequently, they argue, God has in his own mind finite conceptions
of all finite things which He makes. Now it cannot be supposed that His goodness was ever
idle; for if it were, there should be ascribed to Him an awakening to activity in time, from
a past eternity of inactivity, as if He repented of an idleness that had no beginning, and
proceeded, therefore, to make a beginning of work. This being the case, they say it must be
that the same things are always repeated, and that as they pass, so they are destined always
to return, whether amidst all these changes the world remains the same,—the world which
has always been, and yet was created,—or that the world in these revolutions is perpetually
dying out and being renewed; otherwise, if we point to a time when the works of God were
begun, it would be believed that He considered His past eternal leisure to be inert and indol-
ent, and therefore condemned and altered it as displeasing to Himself. Now if God is sup-
posed to have been indeed always making temporal things, but different from one another,
and one after the other, so, that He thus came at last to make man, whom He had never
made before, then it may seem that He made man not with knowledge (for they suppose
no knowledge can comprehend the infinite succession of creatures), but at the dictate of
the hour, as it struck him at the moment, with a sudden and accidental change of mind.
On the other hand, say they, if those cycles be admitted, and if we suppose that the same
temporal things are repeated, while the world either remains identical through all these ro-
tations, or else dies away and is renewed, then there is ascribed to God neither the slothful
ease of a past eternity, nor a rash and unforeseen creation. And if the same things be not
thus repeated in cycles, then they cannot by any science or prescience be comprehended in
their endless diversity. Even though reason could not refute, faith would smile at these ar-
gumentations, with which the godless endeavor to turn our simple piety from the right way,
that we may walk with them “in a circle.” But by the help of the Lord our God, even reason,
and that readily enough, shatters these revolving circles which conjecture frames. For that
which specially leads these men astray to refer their own circles to the straight path of truth,
is, that they measure by their own human, changeable, and narrow intellect the divine mind,
which is absolutely unchangeable, infinitely capacious, and without succession of thought,
counting all things without number. So that saying of the apostle comes true of them, for,
What Defence is Made by Sound Faith Regarding God’s Unchangeable Counsel and Will, Against the Reasonings of Those Who Hold that the Works of God are Eternally Repeated in Revolving Cycles that Restore All Things as They Were.
541
What Defence is Made by Sound Faith Regarding God’s Unchangeable Counsel…