Chapter 23.—Of the Error in Which the Doctrine of Origen is Involved.
But it is much more surprising that some even of those who, with ourselves, believe that
there is one only source of all things, and that no nature which is not divine can exist unless
originated by that Creator, have yet refused to accept with a good and simple faith this so
good and simple a reason of the world’s creation, that a good God made it good; and that
the things created, being different from God, were inferior to Him, and yet were good, being
created by none other than He. But they say that souls, though not, indeed, parts of God,
but created by Him, sinned by abandoning God; that, in proportion to their various sins,
they merited different degrees of debasement from heaven to earth, and diverse bodies as
prison-houses; and that this is the world, and this the cause of its creation, not the production
of good things, but the restraining of evil. Origen is justly blamed for holding this opinion.
For in the books which he entitles περὶ αρχῶν, that is, Of Origins, this is his sentiment, this
218
his utterance. And I can not sufficiently express my astonishment, that a man so erudite
and well versed in ecclesiastical literature, should not have observed, in the first place, how
opposed this is to the meaning of this authoritative Scripture, which, in recounting all the
works of God, regularly adds, “And God saw that it was good;” and, when all were completed,
inserts the words, “And God saw everything that He had made, and, behold, it was very
good.”496 Was it not obviously meant to be understood that there was no other cause of
the world’s creation than that good creatures should be made by a good God? In this creation,
had no one sinned, the world would have been filled and beautified with natures good
without exception; and though there is sin, all things are not therefore full of sin, for the
great majority of the heavenly inhabitants preserve their nature’s integrity. And the sinful
will though it violated the order of its own nature, did not on that account escape the laws
of God, who justly orders all things for good. For as the beauty of a picture is increased by
well-managed shadows, so, to the eye that has skill to discern it, the universe is beautified
even by sinners, though, considered by themselves, their deformity is a sad blemish.
In the second place, Origen, and all who think with him, ought to have seen that if it
were the true opinion that the world was created in order that souls might, for their sins,
be accommodated with bodies in which they should be shut up as in houses of correction,
the more venial sinners receiving lighter and more ethereal bodies, while the grosser and
graver sinners received bodies more crass and grovelling, then it would follow that the
devils, who are deepest in wickedness, ought, rather than even wicked men, to have earthly
bodies, since these are the grossest and least ethereal of all. But in point of fact, that we
might see that the deserts of souls are not to be estimated by the qualities of bodies, the
wickedest devil possesses an ethereal body, while man, wicked, it is true, but with a
wickedness small and venial in comparison with his, received even before his sin a body of
496 Gen. i. 31.
Of the Error in Which the Doctrine of Origen is Involved.
498
Of the Error in Which the Doctrine of Origen is Involved.