Whether the Donatists’ clergy should be
re-ordained was only a point of discipline; for the Donatists retained
Episcopacy. Therefore the African fathers, as they leave other
churches to their liberty, so at the same time they declare that they
would continue their old practice, and leave every bishop to act
according to his own discretion in this matter. Probably, one
great motive, besides that of peace, which they had to this, was the
great scarcity of clergymen in Africa, of which Aurelius complains in
his speech, inserted into the Acts before Canon 77 (61), and proposes
that they send to the bishops of Rome and Milan for a supply. And
that this was the true reason, does in some measure appear from the
words of the Latin canon at large, in which the occasion of this decree
is said to be propter necessitatem. And this is the most
probable reason why it is left to the discretion of the bishop, whether
to admit Donatist clergymen as such, if he had occasion for their
service. And after all it is clear from this very canon, that
other churches had determined this point the contrary way.
Therefore Mr. Calamy exceeds when he says: “As for the
Donatists, all agree that their orders were acknowledged.”
Further, he would have it thought probable that orders were not always
conferred among the Donatists by persons superior to presbyters.
This he would infer from the great number of the bishops of that
faction in Africa, viz., 278, many of which (says he) could be no more
than parish ministers. But why so? Were there not above
four hundred Catholic bishops? And why not as many of one side as
the other? If our dissenters of any sort had fallen into the
Episcopal form of government, no question but they would have had a
bishop in every city at least, and equalled our church in the number of
prelates.