296
man has a right to be judged by his own deeds, not to be blamed for those of others; and in
this present case, while he accuses us, and points his bitterness at us, in truth he is con-
demning no one but himself. For if it is reprehensible to bestow indestructibility on God,
and this is done by no one but himself, is not our slanderer his own accuser, assailing his
own statements and not ours? And with regard to the term indestructibility, we assert that
as the life which is endless is rightly called indestructible, so that which is without beginning
is rightly called ungenerate. And yet Eunomius says that we lend Him the primacy over all
created things simply by reference to the ages.
I pass in silence his blasphemy in reducing God the Only-begotten to a level with all
created things, and, in a word, allowing to the Son of God no higher honour than theirs.
Still, for the sake of my more intelligent hearers, I will here give an instance of his insensate
malice. Basil, he says, lends God the primacy over all things by reference to the ages. What
unintelligible nonsense is this! Man is made God’s patron, and gives to God a primacy owing
to the ages! What is this vain flourish of baseless expressions, seeing that our Master simply
says that whatever in the Divine essence transcends the measurable distances of the ages in
either direction is called by certain distinctive names, in the case of Him Who, as saith the
Apostle, hath neither beginning of days nor end of life1186, in order that the distinction of
the conception might be marked by distinction in the names. And yet on this account Eun-
omius has the effrontery to write, that to call that which is anterior to all beginning ungen-
erate, and again that which is circumscribed by no limit, immortal and indestructible, is a
bestowing or lending on our part, and other nonsense of the kind. Moreover, he says that
we divide the ages into two parts, as if he had not read the words he quoted, or as if he were
addressing those who had forgotten his own previous statements. For what says our Master?
“If we look at the time before the Creation, and if passing in thought through the ages we
reflect on the infinitude of the Eternal Life, we signify the thought by the term ungenerate.
And if we turn our thoughts to what follows, and consider the being of God as extending
beyond all ages, we interpret the thought by the word endless or indestructible.” Well, how
does such an account sever the ages in twain, if by such possible words and names we signify
that eternity of God which is equally observable from every point of view, in all things the
same, unbroken in continuity? For seeing that human life, moving from stage to stage, ad-
vances in its progress from a beginning to an end, and our life here is divided between that
which is past and that which is expected, so that the one is the subject of hope, the other of
memory; on this account, as, in relation to ourselves, we apprehend a past and a future in
this measurable extent, so also we apply the thought, though incorrectly, to the transcendent
nature of God; not of course that God in His own existence leaves any interval behind, or
passes on afresh to something that lies before, but because our intellect can only conceive
1186 Heb. vii. 3.
556
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.