23. Again, the illustration of the Light and the
Radiance has this meaning. For the Saints have not said that the Word
was related to God as fire kindled from the heat of the sun, which is
commonly put out again, for this is an external work and a creature of
its author, but they all preach of Him as Radiance Athan.’s ordinary illustration is, as here, not from
‘fire,’ but from ‘radiance,’ ἀπαύγασμα, after S. Paul [i.e. Hebrews] and the Author of the Book of
Wisdom, meaning by radiance the light which a light diffuses by means
of the atmosphere. On the other hand Arius in his letter to Alexander,
Epiph. Hær. 69. 7. speaks against the doctrine of Hieracas
that the Son was from the Father as a light from a light or as a lamp
divided into two, which after all was Arian doctrine. Athanasius refers
to fire, Orat. iv. §2 and 10, but still to fire and its
radiance. However we find the illustration of fire from fire, Justin.
Tryph. 61. Tatian contr. Græc. 5. At this early day
the illustration of radiance might have a Sabellian bearing, as that of
fire in Athan.’s had an Arian. Hence Justin protests against
those who considered the Son as ‘like the sun’s light in
the heaven,’ which ‘when it sets, goes away with it,’
whereas it is as ‘fire kindled from fire.’ Tryph.
128. Athenagoras, however, like Athanasius, says ‘as light from
fire,’ using also the word ἀπό&
207·ῥοια, effluence:
vid. also Orig. Periarch. i. 2. n. 4. Tertull. Ap. 21.
Theognostus, quoted infr. §25.,
thereby to signify His being from the essence, proper and indivisible,
and His oneness with the Father. This also will secure His true
unchangableness and immutability; for how can these be His, unless He
be proper Offspring of the Father’s essence? for this too must be
taken to confirm His identity with His own Father. Our explanation then
having so religious an aspect, Christ’s enemies should not be
startled at the ‘One in essence,’ either, since this term
also has a sound sense and good reasons. Indeed, if we say that the
Word is from the essence of God (for after what has been said this must
be a phrase admitted by them), what does this mean but the truth and
eternity of the essence from which He is begotten? for it is not
different in kind, lest it be combined with the essence of God as
something foreign and unlike it. Nor is He like only outwardly, lest He
seem in some respect or wholly to be other in essence, as brass shines
like gold and silver like tin. For these are foreign and of other
nature, are separated off from each other in nature and virtues, nor is
brass proper to gold, nor is the pigeon born from the dove vid.
de Syn. §41.; but though they are considered like, yet they
differ in essence. If then it be thus with the Son, let Him be a
creature as we are, and not One in essence; but if the Son is Word,
Wisdom, Image of the Father, Radiance, He must in all reason be One in
essence. For unless it be proved that He is not from God, but an
instrument different in nature and different in essence, surely the
Council was sound in its doctrine and correct in its decree As
‘of the essence’ declared that our Lord was
uncreate, so ‘one in essence’ declared that He was
equal with the Father; no term derived from
‘likeness,’ even ‘like in essence’ answering
for this purpose, for such phrases might all be understood of
resemblance or representation. vid. §20, notes 8,
9..