It was in fact the controversies of the second
century that produced a theology in the Catholic Church,—that in
a sense produced the Catholic Church itself. The idea of the Church as
distinct from and embracing the Churches is a New Testament idea (Eph. v. 25, cf. 1 Cor. xv. 9, &c.), and the name
‘Catholic’ occurs at the beginning of the second century
(Lightfoot’s note on Ign. Smyrn. 8); but the Gnostic and
Montanist controversies compelled the Churches which held fast to the
παράδοσις of
the Apostles to close their ranks (episcopal federation) and to reflect
upon their creed. The Baptismal Creed (Rom. x. 9, Acts viii. 37, Text. Rec.,
cf. 1 Cor. xv. 3–4)
began to serve as a tessera or passport of right belief, and as
a regulative standard, a ‘rule of faith.’ The ‘limits
of the Christian Church’ began to be more clearly defined
(Stanton, ubi supr. p. 167).