Enough, however, of these
matters. But it might be well not to leave his next point unanswered;
yet let us pass over in silence the comic interlude, where our clever
orator shows his youthful conceit, whether in jest or in earnest, under
the impression that he will thereby have an advantage in his argument.
For certainly no one will force us to join either with those whose eyes
are set askance in distorting our sight, or with those who are stricken
with strange disease in being contorted, or in their bodily leaps and
plunges. We shall pity them, but we shall not depart from our settled
state of mind. He says, then, turning his discourse upon the subject to
our master, as if he were really engaging him face to face, “Thou
shalt be taken in thine own snare.” For as Basil had said The
reference is to S. Basil adv. Eunomium II. 12 (p. 247 in Ben.
ed.) that what is good is always present with God
Who is over all, and that it is good to be the Father of such a
Son,—that so what is good was never absent from Him, nor was it
the Father’s will to be without the Son, and when He willed He
did not lack the power, but having the power and the will to be in the
mode in which it seemed good to Him, He also always possessed the Son
by reason of His always willing that which is good (for this is the
direction in which the intention of our father’s remarks tends),
Eunomius pulls this in pieces beforehand, and puts forward to overthrow
what has been said some such argument as this, introduced from his
extraneous philosophy:—“What will become of you,” he
says, “if one of those who have had experience of such arguments
should say, ‘If to create is good and agreeable to the Nature of
God, how is it that what is good and agreeable to His Nature was not
present with Him unoriginately, seeing that God is unoriginate? and
that when there was no hindrance of ignorance or impediment of weakness
or of age in the matter of creation,”—and all the rest that
he collects together and pours out upon himself,—for I may not
say, upon God. Well, if it were possible for our master to answer the
question in person, he would have shown Eunomius what would have become
of him, as
he asked, by setting forth the Divine mystery with that tongue that was
taught of God, and by scourging the champion of deceit with his
refutations, so that it would have been made clear to all men what a
difference there is between a minister of the mysteries of Christ and a
ridiculous buffoon or a setter-forth of new and absurd doctrines. But
since he, as the Apostle says, “being dead, speaketh Cf. Heb. xi. 4” to God, while the other puts forth
such a challenge as though there were no one to answer him, even though
an answer from us may not have equal force when compared with the words
of the great Basil, we shall yet boldly say this in answer to the
questioner:—Your own argument, put forth to overthrow our
statement, is a testimony that in the charges we make against your
impious doctrine we speak truly. For there is no other point we blame
so much as this, that you Reading ὑμᾶς for ἡμᾶς. If the
reading ἡμᾶς, which Oehler
follows, is retained, the force would seem to be “that you think
we ought not to make any difference,” but the construction of the
sentence in this case is cumbrous. think there is no
difference between the Lord of creation and the general body of
creation, and what you now allege is a maintaining of the very things
which we find fault with. For if you are bound to attach exactly what
you see in creation also to the Only-begotten God, our contention has
gained its end: your own statements proclaim the absurdity of the
doctrine, and it is manifest to all, both that we keep our argument in
the straight way of truth, and that your conception of the
Only-begotten God is such as you have of the rest of the
creation.