126 THE SEVEN BOOKS OF [Boox rr.
that you cannot find out anything which seems false to you,
although on every side you see that things are being said
altogether at variance with each other, and inconsistent from
their opposition to each other;* which assuredly would not
happen, if man's curiosity could reach any certainty, or if
that which seemed [to one] to have been really discovered,
was attested by the approval of all the others. It is there-
fore wholly? vain, a useless task, to bring forward something
as though you knew it, or to wish to assert that you know
that which, although it should be true, you see can be refuted ;
or to receive that as true which it may be is not, and is
brought forward as if by men raving. And it is rightly so,
for we do not weigh and guess at? divine things by divine,
but by human methods; and just as we think that anything
should have been made, so we assert that it must be.
58. What, then, are we alone ignorant? do we alone not
know who is the creator, who the former of souls, what cause
fashioned man, whence ills have broken forth, or why the
Supreme Ruler allows them both to exist and be perpetrated,
and does not drive them from the world? have you, indeed,
ascertained and learned any of these things with certainty ?
If you chose to lay aside audacious* conjectures, can you
unfold and disclose whether this world in which we dwell?
was created or founded at some time? if it was founded and
made, by what kind of work, pray, or for what purpose?
Can you bring forward and disclose the reason why it does
not remain fixed and immoveable, but is ever being carried
round in a circular motion? whether it revolves of its own
will and choice, or is turned by the influence of some power?
1 The MS., first four edd., and Oehler read et rerum contrarietatibus dis-
sonare—* and that they disagree from the oppositions of things." Hild.
reads dissonora, a word not met with elsewhere, while the other edd.
merely drop the last two letters, -re, as above; a reading suggested in
the margin of Ursinus.
? Lit., *a most vain thing," etc.
? So the s., LB., Elmenh., Hild., and Oehler, reading conjectamus, the
other edd. reading commetamur or -imur—‘ measure," except Gelenius
and Canterus, who read commentamur—'' muse upon.”
* Lit., ** audacity of." 5 Lit., ** world which holds us."