τινες
ἠθετήκασι. That the Epistle to the Hebrews was not written by Paul is
now commonly acknowledged, and may be regarded as absolutely certain.
It does not itself lay any claim to Pauline authorship; its theology
and style are both non-Pauline; and finally, external testimony is
strongly against its direct connection with Paul. The first persons to
assign the epistle to Paul are Pantænus and Clement of Alexandria
(see below, Bk. VI. chap. 14), and they evidently find it necessary to
defend its Pauline authorship in the face of the objections of others.
Clement, indeed, assumes a Hebrew original, which was translated into
Greek by Luke. Origen (see below, Bk. VI. chap. 25) leaves its
authorship undecided, but thinks it probable that the thoughts are
Paul’s, but the diction that of some one else, who has recorded
what he heard from the apostle. He then remarks that one tradition
assigned it to Clement of Rome, another to Luke. Eusebius himself, in
agreement with the Alexandrians (who, with the exception of Origen,
unanimously accept the Pauline authorship), looks upon it as a work of
Paul, but accepts Clement of Alexandria’s theory that it was
written in Hebrew, and thinks it probable that Clement of Rome was its
translator (see chap. 38, below). In the Western Church, where the
epistle was known very early (e.g. Clement of Rome uses it freely), it
is not connected with Paul until the fourth century. Indeed, Tertullian
(de pudicit. 20) states that it bore the name of Barnabas, and
evidently had never heard that it had been ascribed to any one else.
The influence of the Alexandrians, however, finally prevailed, and from
the fifth century on we find it universally accepted, both East and
West, as an epistle of Paul, and not until the Reformation was its
origin again questioned. Since that time its authorship has been
commonly regarded as an insoluble mystery. Numerous guesses have been
made (e.g. Luther guessed Apollos, and he has been followed by many),
but it is impossible to prove that any of them are correct. For
Barnabas, however, more can be said than for any of the others.
Tertullian expressly connects the epistle with him; and its contents
are just what we should expect from the pen of a Levite who had been
for a time under Paul’s influence, and yet had not received his
Christianity from him; its standpoint, in fact, is Levitic, and
decidedly non-Pauline, and yet reveals in many places the influence of
Pauline ideas. Still further, it is noticeable that in the place where
the Epistle to the Hebrews is first ascribed to Paul, there first
appears an epistle which is ascribed (quite wrongly; see below, chap.
25, note 20) to Barnabas. May it not be (as has been suggested by Weiss
and others) that the anonymous Epistle to the Hebrews was originally
accepted in Alexandria as the work of Barnabas, but that later it was
ascribed to Paul; and that the tradition that Barnabas had written an
epistle, which must still have remained in the Church, led to the
ascription of another anonymous epistle to him? We seem thus most
easily to explain the false ascription of the one epistle to Paul, and
the false ascription of the other to Barnabas. It may be said that the
claims of both Barnabas and Apollos have many supporters, while still
more attempt no decision. In regard to the canonicity of the epistle
there seems never to have been any serious dispute, and it is this fact
doubtless which did most to foster the belief in its Pauline authorship
from the third century on. For the criterion of canonicity more and
more came to be looked upon as apostolicity, direct or indirect. The
early Church had cared little for such a criterion. In only one place
does Eusebius seem to imply that doubts existed as to its
canonicity,—in Bk. VI. chap. 13, where he classes it with the
Book of Wisdom, and the Epistles of Barnabas, Clement, and Jude, among
the antilegomena. But in view of his treatment of it elsewhere
it must be concluded that he is thinking in that passage not at all of
its canonicity, but of its Pauline authorship, which he knows is
disputed by some, and in reference to which he uses the same
word, ἀντιλέγεσθαι, in the present sentence. Upon the canonicity of the
epistle, see still further chap. 25, note 1. For a discussion of the
epistle, see especially the N. T. Introductions of Weiss and
Holtzmann.