what has been quoted,866 speaks thus concerning the death of Philip and his daughters:
“After him867 there were four prophetesses, the daughters of Philip, at Hierapolis in Asia.
Their tomb is there and the tomb of their father.” Such is his statement.
5. But Luke, in the Acts of the Apostles, mentions the daughters of Philip who were at
that time at Cæsarea in Judea with their father, and were honored with the gift of prophecy.
His words are as follows: “We came unto Cæsarea; and entering into the house of Philip
the evangelist, who was one of the seven, we abode with him. Now this man had four
daughters, virgins, which did prophesy.”868
6. We have thus set forth in these pages what has come to our knowledge concerning
the apostles themselves and the apostolic age, and concerning the sacred writings which
they have left us, as well as concerning those which are disputed, but nevertheless have been
866 The agreement of the two accounts is not perfect, as Polycrates reports that two daughters were buried
at Hierapolis and one at Ephesus, while Proclus puts them all four at Hierapolis. But the report of Polycrates
deserves our credence rather than that of Proclus, because, in the first place, Polycrates was earlier than Proclus;
in the second place, his report is more exact, and it is hard to imagine how, if all four were really buried in one
place, the more detailed report of Polycrates could have arisen, while on the other hand it is quite easy to explain
the rise of the more general but inexact account of Proclus; for with the general tradition that Philip and his
daughters lived and died in Hierapolis needed only to be combined the fact that he had four daughters, and
Proclus’ version was complete. In the third place, Polycrates’ report bears the stamp of truth as contrasted with
mere legend, because it accounts for only three daughters, while universal tradition speaks of four. How Eusebius
could have overlooked the contradiction it is more difficult to explain. He can hardly have failed to notice it,
but was undoubtedly unable to account for the difference, and probably considered it too small a matter to
concern himself about. He was quite prone to accept earlier accounts just as they stood, whether contradictory
or not. The fact that they had been recorded was usually enough for him, if they contained no improbable or
fabulous stories. He cannot be accused of intentional deception at this point, for he gives the true accounts side
by side, so that every reader might judge of the agreement for himself. Upon the confusion of the apostle and
evangelist, see above, note 6.
867 I read μετὰ τοῦτον with the majority of the mss., with Burton, Routh, Schwegler, Heinichen, &c., instead
of μετὰ τοῦτο, which occurs in some mss. and in Rufinus, and is adopted by Valesius, Crusè, and others. As
Burton says, the copyists of Eusebius, not knowing to whom Proclus here referred, changed τοῦτον to τοῦτο;
but if we had the preceding context we should find that Proclus had been referring to some prophetic man such
as the Montanists were fond of appealing to in support of their position. Schwegler suggests that it may have
been the Quadratus mentioned in chap. 37, but this is a mere guess. As the sentence stands isolated from its
connection, τοῦτον is the harder reading, and could therefore have more easily been changed into τοῦτο than
the latter into τοῦτον.
868 Acts xxi. 8, 9. Eusebius clearly enough considers Philip the apostle and Philip the evangelist identical.
Upon this identification, see note 6, above.
346
The Death of John and Philip.