Chapter 25.—46. Sedatus of Tuburbo1681 said: "Inasmuch as water, sanctified by the
prayer of the priest in the Church, washes away sins, just so much does it multiply sins when
infected, as by a cancer, with the words of heretics. Wherefore one must strive, with all such
491
efforts as conduce to peace, that no one who has been infected and tainted by heretical error
should refuse to receive the one true baptism, with which whosoever is not baptized shall
not inherit the kingdom of heaven."1682
47. To this we answer, that if the water is not sanctified, when through want of skill the
priest who prays utters some words of error, many, not only of the bad, but of the good
brethren in the Church itself, fail to sanctify the water. For the prayers of many are corrected
every day on being recited to men of greater learning, and many things are found in them
contrary to the Catholic faith. Supposing, then, that it were shown that some persons were
baptized when these prayers had been uttered over the water, will they be bidden to be
baptized afresh? Why not? Because generally the fault in the prayer is more than counter-
balanced by the intent of him who offers it; and those fixed words of the gospel, without
which baptism cannot be consecrated, are of such efficacy, that, by their virtue, anything
faulty that is uttered in the prayer contrary to the rule of faith is made of no effect, just as
the devil is excluded by the name of Christ. For it is clear that if a heretic utters a faulty
prayer, he has no good intent of love whereby that want of skill may be compensated, and
therefore he is like any envious or spiteful person in the Catholic Church itself, such as
Cyprian proves to exist within the Church. Or one might offer some prayer, as not unfre-
quently happens, in which he should speak against the rule of faith, since many rush into
the use of prayers which are composed not only by unskillful men who love to talk, but even
by heretics, and in the simplicity of ignorance, not being able to discern their true character,
use them, thinking they are good; and yet what is erroneous in them does not vitiate what
is right, but rather it is rendered null thereby, just as in the man of good hope and approved
faith, who yet is but a man, if in anything he be otherwise minded, what he holds aright is
not thereby vitiated until God reveal to him also that in which he is otherwise minded. 1683
But supposing that the man himself is wicked and perverse, then, if he should offer an upright
prayer, in no part contrary to the Catholic faith, it does not follow that because the prayer
is right the man himself is also right; and if over some he offer an erroneous prayer, God is
present to uphold the words of His gospel, without which the baptism of Christ cannot be
consecrated, and He Himself consecrates His sacrament, that in the recipient, either before
he is baptized, or when he is baptized, or at some future time when he turns in truth to God,
1681 Tuburbo (Thuburbo) was in the ecclesiastical province of Zeugitana. Sedatus is not unlikely the same
as the one mentioned in Cypr. Epp. iv., lxvii., lxx.
1682 Conc. Carth sec. 18.
1683 Phil. iii. 15.
Chapter 25
893
Chapter 25