vER. 19—21. ST. JOHN. 553
Me, what I have saidunto them : behold,theyknow
what I said.
CHRYS. As theycouldbringno chargeagainstChrist,theyChrys,
askedHim ofHis disciples:The highpriestthenaskedJesus\^^\ 3,
ofHis disciples;perhapswhere theywe're,and on what ac
countHe had collectedthem ; he wishedto provethatHe
was a seditiousand factiouspersonwhom no one attended
to,except His own disciples.THEOPHYL. He asks Him
moreoverof His doctrine,what itwas,whetheropposedto
Moses and the law,thathe might take occasiontherebyto
put Him to deathas an enemy of God. ALCUIN. He does
not ask in orderto know the truth,but to findout some
chargeagainstHim, on whichtodeliverHim to theRoman
Governorto be condemned. But our Lord so tempersHis
answer,asneithertoconcealthetruth,noryetto appearto
defendHimself: Jesusansweredhim,I spakeopenlyto the
world; I evertaughtin the synagogue,and in the temple,
whithertheJews alwaysresort;and in secrethave I said
nothing. AUG. There isa difficultyhere not to be passedAug.Tr.over: ifHe did not speakopenlyeven to His disciples,butcxm'
onlypromisedthatHe would do so at some time,how was
it thatHe spoke openlyto the world? He spoke more
openlytoHis disciplesafterwards,when theyhad withdrawn
from the crowd; forHe then explainedHis parables,the
meaning of which He concealedfrom the others. When
He saysthen,/ spakeopenlyto theworld,He must be un
derstoodto mean, withinthe hearingof many. So in one
senseHe spoke openly,i.e.in thatmany heard Him ; in
anothersensenotopenly,i.e.inthattheydidnot understand
Him. His speakingapartwithHis discipleswas not speak
ing in secret;forhow couldHe speakin secretbeforethe
multitude,especiallywhen thatsmallnumber of His dis
ciplesweretomake known what He saidtoa much larger?
THEOPHYL. He refersheretotheprophecyofEsaias;I havelsa.45,19.
not spokenin secret,in a dark placeof theearth. CHRYS. chrys.
Or, He spokein secret,but not,asthesethought,from fear,^™KL
or toexcitesedition; but onlywhen whatHe saidwas above
the understandingof the many. To establishthe matter,
however,upon superabundantevidence,He adds,Why askest