Leo’s petition for a new Synod was now granted,
but the place of meeting was to be in the East, not in the West, as
more convenient for the Emperor. In the interval S.
Flavian’s body was brought by reverent hands to Constantinople
and buried in the church of the Apostles, and a still more hopeful sign
of the times—Anatolius and many other bishops signed the
Tome. Hitherto Leo had asked that both councils (that which had
condemned and that which had acquitted Eutyches of heresy) should be
treated as null and void, and that the matter should be discussed de
novo. Now, however, he shows a significant change of
front: the Faith, he maintains, is decided: nothing needs
now to be done but to reject the heretics and to use proper caution in
re-admitting the penitents: there is no occasion for a general
council. And consequently he sends bishop Lucentius and Basil a
presbyter as legates to assist Anatolius in this matter of rejection
and re-admission. But, as the Emperor adhered to his
determination, Leo was obliged to give way, and though still declining
to attend in person, sent bishop Paschasinus of Sicily and Boniface a
presbyter with written instructions to act with the former two as his
representatives; Julian of Cos, who from his knowledge of Greek and
Eastern affairs was a most useful addition, was also asked to be of the
number. Nicæa in Bithynia had been fixed upon as the
rendezvous, and there on Sept. 1, 451, 520 bishops assembled 110 others voted by proxy
in absence through their metropolitans (Gore).. The Emperor, however, was too busy and
too anxious over his military operations against Attila and the Huns to
meet them there, and therefore invites them to Chalcedon, which being
on the Bosporus was much nearer to Constantinople. There
accordingly on Oct. 8, in the church of S. Euphemia the Martyr, the
council was at last opened. The Emperor himself was still absent,
but he was well represented by a goodly number of state
officials. In accordance with Leo’s request, Paschasinus,
with his brother legates, presided: next sat Anatolius,
Dioscorus, Maximus of Antioch and Juvenal of Jerusalem, with a copy of
the Gospels in the midst. Leo’s representatives began by
trying to have Dioscorus ejected: they only succeeded in getting
him deposed from his seat of honour and placed in the middle of the
room together with Eusebius of Dorylæum, his accuser, and
Theodoret of Cyrus, the eminent theologian, who was suspected of
Nestorianizing
language. The remainder of the first day was spent in reading the
acts of the Ephesine council, which in the midst of much uproar were
provisionally condemned.