1. The question you send is short and the answer is
clear. There is this passage in the gospel: “Whosoever speaketh a
word against the Son of Man, it shall be forgiven him; but whosoever
speaketh against the Holy Ghost, it shall not be forgiven him neither
in this world nor in the world to come.” Matt. xii. 32.
Now if Novatian affirms that none but Christian renegades can sin
against the Holy Ghost, it is plain that the Jews who blasphemed Christ
were not guilty of this sin. Yet they were wicked husbandmen, they had
slain the prophets, they were then compassing the death of the Lord; Matt. xxi. 33. and so utterly lost were they that the
Son of God told them that it was they whom he had come to save. Matt. xviii. 11. It must be proved to Novatian, therefore,
that the sin which shall never be forgiven is not the blasphemy of men
disembowelled by torture who in their agony deny their Lord, but is the
captious clamor of those who, while they see that God’s works are
the fruit of virtue, ascribe the virtue to a demon and declare the
signs wrought to belong not to the divine excellence but to the devil.
And this is the whole gist of our Saviour’s argument, when He
teaches that Satan cannot be cast out by Satan, and that his kingdom is
not divided against itself. Matt. xii. 25, 26. If it is the
devil’s object to injure God’s creation, how can he wish to
cure the sick and to expel himself from the bodies possessed by him?
Let Novatian prove that of those who have been compelled to sacrifice
before a judge’s tribunal any
has declared of the things written in the gospel that they were wrought
not by the Son of God but by Beelzebub, the prince of the devils; Matt. xii. 24. and then he will be able to make good
his contention that this Viz. denial of
Christ by Christians. is the
blasphemy against the Holy Ghost which shall never be forgiven.