436
Chapter XII.
And the following appear to me to be childish assertions, viz., that “no good general
and leader of great multitudes was ever betrayed; nor even a wicked captain of robbers and
commander of very wicked men, who seemed to be of any use to his associates; but Jesus,
having been betrayed by his subordinates, neither governed like a good general, nor, after
deceiving his disciples, produced in the minds of the victims of his deceit that feeling of
good-will which, so to speak, would be manifested towards a brigand chief.” Now one might
find many accounts of generals who were betrayed by their own soldiers, and of robber
chiefs who were captured through the instrumentality of those who did not keep their bar-
gains with them. But grant that no general or robber chief was ever betrayed, what does
that contribute to the establishment of the fact as a charge against Jesus, that one of His
disciples became His betrayer? And since Celsus makes an ostentatious exhibition of
philosophy, I would ask of him, If, then, it was a charge against Plato, that Aristotle, after
being his pupil for twenty years, went away and assailed his doctrine of the immortality of
the soul, and styled the ideas of Plato the merest trifling? 3254 And if I were still in doubt,
I would continue thus: Was Plato no longer mighty in dialectics, nor able to defend his
views, after Aristotle had taken his departure; and, on that account, are the opinions of
Plato false? Or may it not be, that while Plato is true, as the pupils of his philosophy would
maintain, Aristotle was guilty of wickedness and ingratitude towards his teacher? Nay,
Chrysippus also, in many places of his writings, appears to assail Cleanthes, introducing
novel opinions opposed to his views, although the latter had been his teacher when he was
a young man, and began the study of philosophy. Aristotle, indeed, is said to have been
Plato’s pupil for twenty years, and no inconsiderable period was spent by Chrysippus in the
school of Cleanthes; while Judas did not remain so much as three years with Jesus. 3255 But
from the narratives of the lives of philosophers we might take many instances similar to
those on which Celsus founds a charge against Jesus on account of Judas. Even the Py-
thagoreans erected cenotaphs 3256 to those who, after betaking themselves to philosophy,
fell back again into their ignorant mode of life; and yet neither was Pythagoras nor his fol-
lowers, on that account, weak in argument and demonstration.
3254 τερετίσματα.
3255 [See De Princip., iv. i. 5, where Origen gives the length of our Lord’s ministry as “only a year and a few
months.” S.]
3256 Cf. Clem. Alex., Strom., v. c. ix. [See vol. ii. pp. 457, 458. S.]
Chapter XII
950
Chapter XII