The contention of
those who disapproved of the condemnation of “The Three
Chapters” by the fifth council was not only that the condemnation
of deceased persons was wrong as well as useless, but also that it
impugned the faith of the Council of Chalcedon. For that Council
had not condemned the writers who were now condemned; and two of them,
Theodoret of Cyrus and Ibas of Edessa, had even appeared before it, and
been accepted as orthodox. Further, the condemnation was regarded
as a concession to the Monophysites who had been condemned at
Chalcedon, the writers in question having been peculiarly obnoxious to
the Monophysite party. And it does appear to be the case that a
main motive of the Emperor Justinian in forcing the condemnation of The
Three Chapters on the Church had been to conciliate the Monophysites,
and to induce them to conform. Hence Gregory’s anxiety to
shew that what had been done at the fifth did not touch the faith as
previously defined.