[The point which Chrysostom so anxiously discusses
is much more readily settled by modern interpreters. Thus one of
them says, “All outward acts of beneficence are of no avail
without love. A man may give away his whole estate, or sacrifice
himself, and be in no sense the gainer. He may do all this from
vanity, or from the fear of perdition, or to purchase heaven, and
only increase his condemnation. Religion is no such easy thing.
Men would gladly compound by external acts of beneficence or by
penances for a change of heart; but the thing is impossible.
Thousands indeed are deluded on this point, and think that they can
substitute what is outward for what is inward, but God requires the
heart, and without holiness the most liberal giver or the most
suffering ascetic can never see God.” (Hodge) The address of
our Saviour to the rich young ruler was not intended to furnish a
general rule of action or even to specify a particular kind of
perfection. When he told the earnest enquirer to sell all that he
had the object was to disclose to him his inordinate love of this
world’s goods and so lead him to see how far he was from the
perfection which he had claimed. Chrysostom’s use of this
passage is precisely that which was made by Anthony, the first of
the Fathers of the Desert, and by St. Francis of Assisi, and which
lies at the basis of the whole monastic system. C.]