The reader will be glad to know Harnack’s judgment
in this matter. Writing of the Fifth Council, he says:
“It condemned Origen, as Justinian desired; it condemned the
Three Chapters and consequently the Antiochene theology, as Justinian
desired,” etc., and in a foot-note he explains that he agrees
with “Noris, the Ballerini, Möller (R. Encykl., xi., p. 113)
and Loofs (pp. 287, 291) as against Hefele and
Vincenzi.” Harnack.
Hist. of Dogma, Vol. IV., n. 249 (Eng. Trans.). A few pages
before, he speaks of this last author’s book as “a big work
which falsifies history to justify the theses of Halloix, to
rehabilitate Origen and Vigilius, and on the other hand to
‘remodel’ the Council and partly to bring it into
contempt.” Ibid., p. 245, note
2. Further on
he says: “The fifteen anathemas against Origen, on which
his condemnation at the council was based, contained the following
points.…Since the ‘Three Chapters’ were condemned at
the same time, Origen and Theodore were both got rid
of.…Origen’s doctrines of the consummation, and of spirits
and matter might no longer be maintained. The judgment was
restored to its place, and got back even its literal
meaning.” Ibid., p. 349.