134 INSTITUTES OF THE BOOK I.
selection, but of a foolish and inconsiderate longing. I say no
thing as to the improper and unbecoming form in which they
are presented, or the wanton license in which sculptors and
painters have here indulged, (a point to which I alluded a
little ago, supra, s. 7.) I only say, that though they were
otherwise faultless, they could not be of any utility in
teaching.
13. But, without reference to the above distinction, let us
here consider, whether it is expedient that churches should
contain representations of any kind, whether of events or
human forms. First, then, if we attach any weight to the
authority of the ancient Church, let us remember, that for
five hundred years, during which religion was in a more pros
perous condition, and a purer doctrine flourished, Christian
churches were completely free from visible representations,
(see Preface, and Book IV., c. ix. s. 9.) Hence their first
admission as an ornament to churches took place after the
purity of the ministry had somewhat degenerated. I will
not dispute as to the rationality of the grounds on which the
first introduction of them proceeded, but if you compare the
two periods, you will find that the latter had greatly declined
from the purity of the times when images were unknown.
What then ? Are we to suppose that those holy fathers, if
they had judged the thing to be useful and salutary, would
have allowed the Church to be so long without it ? Undoubt
edly, because they saw very little or no advantage, and the
greatest danger in it, they rather rejected it intentionally and
on rational grounds, than omitted it through ignorance or
carelessness. This is clearly attested by Augustine in these
words, (Ep. xlix. See also De Civit. Dei, lib. iv. c. 31.)
" When images are thus placed aloft in seats of honour, to be
beheld by those who are praying or sacrificing, though they
have neither sense nor life, yet from appearing as if they had
both, they affect weak minds just as if they lived and
breathed," &c. And again, in another passage, (in Ps. cxii.) he
says, " The effect produced, and in a manner extorted, by the
bodily shape, is, that the mind, being itself in a body, imagines
that a body which is so like its own must be similarly
affected," &c. A little farther on he says, " Images are more