Malchion gained such fame from his controversy with Paul that an
account of him is given by Jerome in his de vir. ill. 71. He
tells us, however, nothing new about him, except that he was the author
of an epistle to the bishops of Alexandria and Rome, referring probably
to the encyclical letter given in the next chapter. We do not know upon
what authority he bases this statement; in fact knowing the character
of his work, we shall probably be safe in assuming that the statement
is no more than a guess on his part. There is nothing improbable in the
report, but we must remember that Jerome is our only authority for it,
and he is in such a case very poor authority (nevertheless, in
Fremantle’s articles, Malchion, in the Dict. of Christ.
Biog., the report is repeated as a fact). Both Eusebius and Jerome
tell us that the report of his discussion with Paul was extant in their
day, and a few fragments of it have been preserved, and are given by
Leontius (de Sectis, III. p. 504, according to
Fremantle).