214 INSTITUTES OF THE [bOOK
a foolish cavil— that, since Pharaoh himself is elsewhere said
to have hardened his own heart, his own will is stated as the
cause of his obduracy ; as though these two things were at
all incompatible with each other, that man should be actuated
by God, and yet at the same time be active himself. But I
retort on them their own objection ; for if hardening denotes
a bars permission, Pharaoh cannot properly be charged with
being the cause of his own obstinacy. Now, how weak and
insipid would be such an interpretation, as though Pharaoh
only permitted himself to be hardened ! Besides, the Scripture
cuts otf all occasion for such cavils. God says, " I will harden
his heart." [p) So, also, Moses says, concerning the inhabitants
of Canaan, that they marched forth to battle, because the Lord
had hardened their hearts
; [q] which is likewise repeated by
another Prophet—"He turned their hearts to hate his peo-
ple." (r) Thus, also, in Isaiah, he declares be will "send the
Assyrian against a hypocritical nation, and will give him a
charge to take the spoil, and to take the prey ; " (s) not that
he meant to teach impious and refractory men a voluntary
obedience, but because he would incline them to execute his
judgments, just as if they had his commands engraven on their
minds. Hence it^ppears that they were impelled by the pos-
itive appointmeht of God. I grant, indeed, that God often
actuates the reprobate by the interposition of Satan ; but in
such a manner that Satan himself acts his part by the Divine
impulse, and proceeds to the extent of the Divine appointment.
Saul was disturbed by an evil spirit ; but it is said to be " from
the Lord ; " (<) to teach us that Saul's madness proceeded from
the righteous vengeance of God. Satan is also said to blind
" the minds of them which believe not ; " {u) but the strength
of the delusion proceeds from God himself, " that they should
believe a lie, who believe not the truth." {v) According to
one view of the subject, it is said, " If the juophet be deceived
when he hath spoken a thing, I the Lord have deceived that
prophet." [w) But, according to another, God is said himself
to " give men over to a reprobate mind,"(a:) and to the vilest
lusts ; because he is the principal author of his own righteous
vengeance, and Satan is only the dispenser of it. But as we
must discuss this subject again in the second book, where we
shall treat of the freedom or slavery of the human will, I think
I have now said, in a brief manner, as much as the occasion re-
quired. The whole may be summed up thus ; that, as the will
of God is said to be the cause of all things, his providence is
established as the governor in all the counsels and works of
{p) Exod. iv. 21. {s) Isaiah x. 6. (») 2 Thess. ii. 10—12
{q) Deut. ii. 30. Joshua xi. 20. \t) 1 Sam. xvi. 14. (lo) Ezek. xiv. 9.
(r) Psalm cv. 25 (m) 2 Cor. iv. 4. (z) Rom. i. 28.