probable, therefore, that immediately after the condemnation of Eustathius, Eulalius was
appointed in his place, perhaps by the same Council, and that after his death, a few months
later, Eusebius, who had meanwhile gone back to Cæsarea, was elected in due order by an-
other Council of neighboring bishops summoned for the purpose, and that he was supported
by a large party of citizens. It is noticeable that the letter written by the Emperor to the
Council, which wished to transfer Eusebius to Antioch (see Vita Const. III. 62), mentions
in its salutation the names of five bishops, but among them is only one (Theodotus) who is
22
elsewhere named as present at the Council which deposed Eustathius, while Eusebius of
Nicomedia, and Theognis of Nicæa, as well as others whom we know to have been on hand
on that occasion, are not referred to by the Emperor. This fact certainly seems to point to
a different council.
It is greatly to Eusebius’ credit that he refused the call extended to him. Had he been
governed simply by selfish ambition he would certainly have accepted it, for the patriarchate
of Antioch stood at that time next to Alexandria in point of honor in the Eastern Church.
The Emperor commended him very highly for his decision, in his epistles to the people of
Antioch and to the Council (Vita Const. III. 60, 62), and in that to Eusebius himself (ib. III.
61). He saw in it a desire on Eusebius’ part to observe the ancient canon of the Church,
which forbade the transfer of a bishop from one see to another. But that in itself can hardly
have been sufficient to deter the latter from accepting the high honor offered him, for it was
broken without scruple on all sides. It is more probable that he saw that the schism of the
Antiochenes would be embittered by the induction into the bishopric of that church of Eu-
stathius’ chief opponent, and that he did not feel that he had a right so to divide the Church
of God. Eusebius’ general character, as known to us, justifies us in supposing that this high
motive had much to do with his decision. We may suppose also that so difficult a place can
have had no very great attractions for a man of his age and of his peace-loving disposition
and scholarly tastes. In Cæsarea he had spent his life; there he had the great library of
Pamphilus at his disposal, and leisure to pursue his literary work. In Antioch he would have
found himself compelled to plunge into the midst of quarrels and seditions of all kinds, and
would have been obliged to devote his entire attention to the performance of his official
duties. His own tastes therefore must have conspired with his sense of duty to lead him to
reject the proffered call and to remain in the somewhat humbler station which he already
occupied.
Not long after the deposition of Eustathius, the Arians and their sympathizers began to
work more energetically to accomplish the ruin of Athanasius, their greatest foe. He had
become Alexander’s successor as bishop of Alexandria in the year 326, and was the acknow-
ledged head of the orthodox party. If he could be brought into discredit, there might be
hopes of restoring Arius to his position in Alexandria, and of securing for Arianism a recog-
nition, and finally a dominating influence in the church at large. To the overthrow of Ath-
35
Continuance of the Arian Controversy. Eusebius' Relations to the Two Pa…