148 ON THE TRINITY. [BOOK V.
reply, If "whatever is spoken of God is spoken according to
substance, then that which is said, " I and the Father are one,"^
is spoken according to substance. Therefore there is one sub-
stance of the Father and the Son. Or if this is not said
according to substance, then something is said of God not
according to substance, and therefore we are no longer com-
pelled to understand unbegotten and begotten according to
substance. It is also said of the Son, "He thought it not
robbery to be equal with God." ^ We ask, equal according to
what ? For if He is not said to be equal according to sub-
stance, then they admit that something may be said of God
not according to substance. Let them admit, then, that unbe-
gotten and begotten are not spoken according to substance.
And if they do not admit this, on the ground that they will
have all things to be spoken of God according to substance,
then the Son is equal to the Father according to substance.
Chap. iv.—The accidental always implies some change in the thing.
5. That which is accidental commonly implies that it can
be lost by some change of the thing to which it is an accident.
For although some accidents are said to be inseparable, which
in Greek are called a')((jt)pi<jTa, as the colour black is to the
feather of a raven ; yet the feather loses that colour, not
indeed so long as it is a feather, but because the feather is not
always. Wherefore the matter itself is changeable ; and when-
as that animal or that feather ceases to be, and the whole of
that body is changed and turned into earth, it loses certainly
that colour also. Although the kind of accident, w^hich is
called separable, may likewise be lost, not by separation, but
by change; as, for instance, blackness is called a separable
accident to the hair of men, because hair continuing to be hair
can grow white ; but, if carefully considered, it is sufficiently
apparent, that it is not as if anything departed by separation
away from the head when it grows white, as though blackness
departed thence and went somewhere, and whiteness came in
its place, but that the quality of colour there is turned and
chanc^ed. Therefore there is nothincj accidental in God, because
there is nothing changeable or that may be lost. But if you
iJolmx. 30. =riiil. ii. 6.