ἐπὶ
πᾶσι καὶ τὸ
πρὸς
᾽Αντωνῖνον
βιβλίδιον βιβλίδιον
(libellus) was the technical name for a
petition addressed to the emperor, and does not imply that the work was
a brief one, as Piper supposes. The Apology is mentioned also in
chap. 13, above, and at the beginning of this chapter. Jerome puts it
first in his list, with the words: Melito Asianus, Sardensis
episcopus, librum imperatori M. Antonini Vero, qui Frontonis oratoris
discipulus fuit, pro christiano dogmate dedit. This Apology is no
longer extant, and we have only the fragments which Eusebius gives in
this chapter. As remarked in note 1, above, the extant Syriac
Apology is not a work of Melito’s. The Apology is
mentioned in Jerome’s version of the Chron., and is
assigned to the tenth year of Marcus Aurelius, 120 a.d. The notice is omitted in the Armenian, which,
however, assigns to the eleventh year of Marcus Aurelius the
Apology of Apolinarius, which is connected with that of Melito
in the Ch. Hist. Moreover, a notice of the Apology is
given by Syncellus in connection with the tenth year of Marcus
Aurelius, and also by the Chron. Pasch.; so that it is not
improbable that Eusebius himself mentioned it in his Chron., and
that its omission in the Armenian is a mistake (as Harnack thinks
likely). But though the notice may thus have been made by Eusebius
himself, we are nevertheless not at liberty to accept the date given as
conclusive. We learn from the quotations given by Eusebius that the
work was addressed to the emperor after the death of Lucius Verus, i.e.
after the year 169. Whether before or after the association of Commodus
with his father in the imperial power, which took place in 176, is
uncertain; but I am inclined to think that the words quoted in §7,
below, point to a prospective rather than to a present association of
Commodus in the empire, and that therefore the work was written between
169 and 176. It must be admitted, however, that we can say with
certainty only that the work was written between 169 and 180. Some
would put the work at the beginning of those persecutions which raged
in 177, and there is much to be said for this. But the dates of the
local and minor persecutions, which were so frequent during this
period, are so uncertain that little can be based upon the fact that we
know of persecutions in certain parts of the empire in 177. Piper,
Otto, and others conclude from the fact that the Apology is
mentioned last by Eusebius that it was Melito’s latest work; but
that, though not at all unlikely, does not necessarily follow (see
above, note 1).