28. For where there are weddings, marriages, births, nurses, arts,4228 and weaknesses;
where there are liberty and slavery; where there are wounds, slaughter, and shedding of
blood; where there are lusts, desires, sensual pleasures; where there is every mental passion
arising from disgusting emotions,—there must of necessity be nothing godlike there; nor
can that cleave to a superior nature which belongs to a fleeting race, and to the frailty of
earth. For who, if only he recognises and perceives what the nature of that power is, can
believe either that a deity had the generative members, and was deprived of them by a very
base operation; or that he at one time cut off the children sprung from himself, and was
punished by suffering imprisonment; or that he, in a way, made civil war upon his father,
and deprived him of the right of governing; or that he, filled with fear of one younger when
overcome, turned to flight, and hid in remote solitudes, like a fugitive and exile? Who, I say,
can believe that the deity reclined at men’s tables, was troubled on account of his avarice,
deceived his suppliants by an ambiguous reply, excelled in the tricks of thieves, committed
adultery, acted as a slave, was wounded, and in love, and submitted to the seduction of impure
desires in all the forms of lust? But yet you declare all these things both were, and are, in
your gods; and you pass by no form of vice, wickedness, error, without bringing it forward,
in the wantonness of your fancies, to the reproach of the gods. You must, therefore, either
seek out other gods, to whom all these reproaches shall not apply, for they are a human and
486
earthly race to whom they apply; or if there are only these whose names and character you
have declared, by your beliefs you do away with them: for all the things of which you speak
relate to men.
4228 i.e., either the arts which belong to each god (cf. the words in ii. 18: “these (arts) are not the gifts of science,
but the discoveries of necessity”), or, referring to the words immediately preceding, obstetric arts.
Chapter XXVIII.
1161
Chapter XXVIII.