Such were the Acts of the fifth Council. This it
learnt from the third and fourth Councils, and approved; and in this
argument we have brought at once in favour of our opinion the decrees
of three Ecumenical Councils, of Ephesus, of Chalcedon, and the second
Constantinopolitan. The
Emperor Justinian desired that the question concerning the
above-mentioned Three Chapters should be considered in the
Church. He therefore sent for Pope Vigilius to
Constantinople. There he not long after assembled a
council. He and the Orientals thought it of great moment that
these Chapters should be condemned, against the Nestorians, who were
raising their heads to defend them; Vigilius, with the Occidentals,
feared lest this occasion should be taken to destroy the authority of
the Council of Chalcedon: because it was admitted that Theodoret
and Ibas had been received in that Council, whilst Theodore, though
named, was let go without any mark of censure. Though then both
parties easily agreed as to the substance of the Faith, yet the
question had entirely respect to the Faith, it being feared by the one
party lest the Nestorian, by the other lest the Eutychian, enemies of
the Council of Chalcedon should prevail. Vigilius on the 11th of
April, 548, issues his “Judicatum” against the Three
Chapters, saving the authority of the Council of Chalcedon.
Thereupon the Bishops of Africa, Illyria, and Dalmatia, with two of his
own confidential Deacons, withdraw from his communion. In the
year 550 the African Bishops, under Reparatus of Carthage, not only
reject the Judicatum, but anathematize Vigilius himself, and sever him
from Catholic Communion, reserving to him a place for repentance.
At length the Pope publicly withdraws his
“Judicatum.” While the Council is sitting at
Constantinople he publishes his “Constitutum,” in which he
condemns certain propositions of Theodore, but spares his person; the
same respecting Theodoret; but with respect to Ibas, he declares that
his letter was pronounced orthodox by the Council of Chalcedon.
However this may be, so much is clear, that Vigilius, though invited,
declined being present at the council: that nevertheless the
council was held without him; that he published a
“Constitutum,” in which he disapproved of what Theodore,
Theodoret, and Ibas were said to have written against the Faith; but
decreed that their names should be spared because they were considered
to have been received by the fourth Council, or to have died in the
communion of the Church, and to be reserved to the judgment of
God. Concerning the letter of Ibas, he published the following,
that, “understood in the best and most pious sense,” it was
blameless; and concerning the three Chapters generally, he ordered that
after his present declaration ecclesiastics should move no further
question.