Chapter XIX.
Arius is charged with the first of the above-mentioned errors, and refuted by the testi-
mony of St. John. The miserable death of the Heresiarch is described, and the rest of his
blasphemous errors are one by one examined and disproved.
123. Arius, then, says: “There was a time when the Son of God existed not,” but Scripture
saith: “He was,” not that “He was not.” Furthermore, St. John has written: “In the beginning
was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. The same was in the
beginning with God.”1097 Observe how often the verb “was” appears, whereas “was not” is
nowhere found. Whom, then, are we to believe?—St. John, who lay on Christ’s bosom, or
Arius, wallowing amid the outgush of his very bowels?—so wallowing that we might under-
stand how Arius in his teaching showed himself like unto Judas, being visited with like
punishment.
124. For Arius’ bowels also gushed out—decency forbids to say where—and so he burst
asunder in the midst, falling headlong, and besmirching those foul lips wherewith he had
denied Christ. He was rent, even as the Apostle Peter said of Judas, because he “bought a
field with the price of evil-doing, and falling headlong he burst asunder in the midst, and
all his bowels gushed out.”1098 It was no chance manner of death, seeing that like wickedness
was visited with like punishment, to the end that those who denied and betrayed the same
Lord might likewise undergo the same torment.
125. Let us pass on to further points. Arius says: “Before He was born, the Son of God
was not,” but the Scripture saith that all things are maintained in existence by the Son’s office.
How, then, could He, Who existed not, bestow existence upon others? Again, when the
blasphemer uses the words “when” and “before,” he certainly uses words which are marks
of time. How, then, do the Arians deny that time was ere the Son was, and yet will have
things created in time to exist before the Son, seeing that the very words, “when,” “before,”
and “did not exist once,” announce the idea of time?
126. Arius says that the Son of God came into being out of nought. How, then, is He
Son of God—how was He begotten from the womb of the Father—how do we read of Him
as the Word spoken of the heart’s abundance, save to the end that we should believe that
He came forth, as it is written, from the Father’s inmost, unapproachable sanctuary? Now
a son is so called either by means of adoption or by nature, as we are called sons by means
1097 S. John i. 1–3.
1098 Acts i. 18. Arius seems to have been carried off by a terrible attack of cholera or some kindred malady.
See Newman, Arians of the Fourth Century, Ch. 3. § 2, and Robertson, History of the Christian Church, vol. 1.
pp. 301–2, ed. 1875.
Chapter XIX. Arius is charged with the first of the above-mentioned errors, and refuted by the testimony of St. John. The miserable death of the Heresiarch is described, and the rest of his blasphemous errors are one by one examined and disproved.
489
Chapter XIX. Arius is charged with the first of the above-mentioned errors,…