becomes to us who have put Him on the beginning of the ways of salvation, that He may
make us the work of His own hands, new modelling us from the evil mould of sin once more
to His own image. He is at once our foundation before the world to come, according to the
words of Paul, who says, “Other foundation can no man lay than that is laid373,” and it is
true that “before the springs of the waters came forth, before the mountains were settled,
118
before He made the depths, and before all hills, He begetteth Me374.” For it is possible, accord
ing to the usage of the Book of Proverbs, for each of these phrases, taken in a tropical sense,
to be applied to the Word375. For the great David calls righteousness the “mountains of
God376,” His judgments “deeps377,” and the teachers in the Churches “fountains,” saying
“Bless God the Lord from the fountains of Israel378”; and guilelessness he calls “hills,” as he
shows when he speaks of their skipping like lambs379. Before these therefore is born in us
He Who for our sakes was created as man, that of these things also the creation may find
place in us. But we may, I think, pass from the discussion of these points, inasmuch as the
truth has been sufficiently pointed out in a few words to well-disposed readers; let us proceed
to what Eunomius says next.
“Existing in the Beginning,” he says, “not without beginning.” In what fashion does he
who plumes himself on his superior discernment understand the oracles of God? He declares
Him Who was in the beginning Himself to have a beginning: and is not aware that if He
Who is in the beginning has a beginning, then the Beginning itself must needs have another
beginning. Whatever He says of the beginning he must necessarily confess to be true of Him
Who was in the beginning: for how can that which is in the beginning be severed from the
beginning? and how can any one imagine a “was not” as preceding the “was”? For however
far one carries back one’s thought to apprehend the beginning, one most certainly under-
stands as one does so that the Word which was in the beginning (inasmuch as It cannot be
separated from the beginning in which It is) does not at any point of time either begin or
cease its existence therein. Yet let no one be induced by these words of mine to separate into
two the one beginning we acknowledge. For the beginning is most assuredly one, wherein
is discerned, indivisibly, that Word Who is completely united to the Father. He who thus
thinks will never leave heresy a loophole to impair his piety by the novelty of the term “un-
generate.” But in Eunomius’ next propositions his statements are like bread with a large
373 1 Cor. iii. 11.
374 Prov. viii. 23–25 (not quite verbal, from the LXX.).
375 Or “to be brought into harmony with Christian doctrine” (ἐφαρμόσθῆναι τῷ λόγω).
376 Ps. xxxvi. 6.
377 Ps. xxxvi. 6.
378 Ps. lxviii. 26 (LXX.).
379 Cf. Ps. cxiv. 6
226
He explains the phrase “The Lord created Me,” and the argument about the…