38. But if they say this of the Saviour also, it
follows that He is neither very God nor very Son, nor like the Father,
nor in any wise has God for a Father of His being according to essence,
but of the mere grace given to Him, and for a Creator of His being
according to essence, after the similitude of all others. And being
such, as they maintain, it will be manifest further that He had not the
name ‘Son’ from the first, if so be it was the prize of
works done and of that very same advance which He made when He became
man, and took the form of the servant; but then, when, after becoming
‘obedient unto death,’ He was, as the text says,
‘highly exalted,’ and received that ‘Name’ as a
grace, ‘that in the Name of Jesus every knee should bow Phil. ii. 8..’ What then was before this, if then
He was exalted, and then began to be worshipped, and then was called
Son, when He became man? For He seems Himself not to have promoted the
flesh at all, but rather to have been Himself promoted through it, if,
according to their perverseness, He was then exalted and called Son,
when He became man. What then was before this? One must urge the
question on them again, to make it understood what their irreligious
doctrine results in The
Arians perhaps more than other heretics were remarkable for bringing
objections against the received view, rather than forming a consistent
theory of their own. Indeed the very vigour and success of their
assault upon the truth lay in its being a mere assault, not a positive
and substantive teaching. They therefore, even more than others, might
fairly be urged on to the consequences of their positions. Now the text
in question, as it must be interpreted if it is to serve as an
objection, was an objection also to the received doctrine of the
Arians. They considered that our Lord was above and before all
creatures from the first, and their Creator; how then could He be
exalted above all? They surely, as much as Catholics, were obliged to
explain it of our Lord’s manhood. They could not then use it as a
weapon against the Church, until they took the ground of Paul of
Samosata.. For if the Lord be
God, Son, Word, yet was not all these before He became man, either He
was something else beside these, and afterwards became partaker of them
for His virtue’s sake, as we have said; or they must adopt the
alternative (may it return upon their heads!) that He was not before
that time, but is wholly man by nature and nothing more. But this is no
sentiment of the Church. but of the Samosatene and of the present Jews.
Why then, if they think as Jews, are they not circumcised with them
too, instead of pretending Christianity, while they are its foes? For
if He was not, or was indeed, but afterwards was promoted, how were all
things made by Him, or how in Him, were He not perfect, did the Father
delight Prov. viii.
30.? And He, on the other hand, if now
promoted, how did He before rejoice in the presence of the Father? And,
if He received His worship after dying, how is Abraham seen to worship
Him in the tent De
Syn. 27 (15)., and Moses in the
bush? and, as Daniel saw, myriads of myriads, and thousands of
thousands were ministering unto Him? And if, as they say, He had His
promotion now, how did the Son Himself make mention of that His glory
before and above the world, when He said, ‘Glorify Thou Me, O
Father, with the glory which I had with Thee before the world was John xvii. 5..’ If, as they say, He was then
exalted, how did He before that ‘bow the heavens and come
down;’ and again, ‘The Highest gave His thunder Ps. xviii. 9,
13.?’ Therefore, if, even before the world
was made, the Son had that glory,
and was Lord of glory and the Highest, and descended from heaven, and
is ever to be worshipped, it follows that He had not promotion from His
descent, but rather Himself promoted the things which needed promotion;
and if He descended to effect their promotion, therefore He did not
receive in reward the name of the Son and God, but rather He Himself
has made us sons of the Father, and deified men by becoming Himself
man.